New Multispectral Approaches to Study of Gamma Ray Bursts

haddockhellskitchenUrban and Civil

Nov 15, 2013 (3 years and 11 months ago)


New Multispectral Approaches
to Study of Gamma Ray

René Hudec

Astronomical Institute, CZ
251 65 Ondrejov, Czech Republic

Email: rhudec@

The identification of GRB afterglows: X
rays, optical, radio

Recently, the GRBs are discover
ed ONLY in ramma rays. However,

Nearly 90 % of all GRBs detected by BeppoSAX have an X
ray afterglow

Nearly 45% of detected GRBs by BeppoSAX have an optical afterglow

Nearly 40% of detected GRBs by BeppoSAX have a radio afterglow

These results justify t
he searches for GRBs INDEPENDENTLY at other
wavelengths, especially in X
rays and in optical. The GRBs can be detected not
only in gamma rays but at other wavelengths as well.

Since the GRB emission is believed to be beamed, with opening angle increasing

with wavelength and with time, the fraction of GRBs observable at longer
wavelengths if compared with gamma
rays is believed to be larger

Advantages of observing GRBs at other wavelengths:


larger sample and hence better statistics: the total numbe
r of detected triggers
is expected to be larger


this means also better statistics of related host galaxies, redshift distributions,


precise astrometry and localization accuracy (if compared with gamma rays)


constraints on beaming and other paramete


cost effective approach


multispectral analyses in real time, better physical understanding


The UV flashes predicted by some theories such as Protheroe and Bednarek
1999 could be detected and studied. The corresponding delays regarding GRBs
could serv
e to study the nature of the sources. This can be addressed only by
surveys, not by follow
up devices since the flashes may preceed the GRBs
( Protheroe and Bednarek, 1999).

Feasibility of Independent X
ray Searches

The independent X
ray sear
ches for GRBs require sensitive X
ray monitoring of
the sky. The X
ray telescopes in recent use however mostly have FOV limited to 1
deg or even less.

Recently designed and developed wide field
Eye X
ray telescopes

one very promising possibi
lity. FOV of 1000 deg

or even more is easily feasible
in these devices.

The recently developed prototypes of wide field X
ray telescopes of Lobster Eye
type confirm the technical feasibility of such analyses.

The first prototypes of Lobster Eye Telescop
es have been designed, developed
and tested in the Czech Republic. The tests both in optical as well as in X
confirm the performance identical with the calculations. One module has FOV of
~ 40 deg
; more can be obtained by multiplying of analogous mo

LE Telescopes and GRB X
ray afterglows

the expected rate of GRBs is 1 per day, however the theoretical prediction
assumes larger beaming angle in X
rays if compared with gamma rays, hence
the actual rate of X
ray afteglows may be larger

the s
ensitivity of LE telescopes is sufficient enough to detect the recently
discovered X
ray GRB afterglows

the localization accuracy of the LE telescopes is of order of 1 arcmin,
substantially exceeding the recent localization accuracy of most gamma ray
ruments (2 deg and more)

The proposed strategy for locating GRBs upon their X
ray fading counterparts:

a pointed LE telescope with FOV of 12 x 12 deg + a crude positioning
instrument like BATSE/CGRO

the 2D telescope will be pointed immediately at the GR
B crude position and
stay on it for ~ 24 hrs

then the sensitivity of ~ 10


or better may be achieved (0.5

keV energy range)

this is sufficient to position the fading X
ray GRB counterpart to 1 arcmin or
better, as well as obtain the l
ight curve

More science with LE telescopes

the additional science of LE X
ray telescopes includes supernova explosions,
high energy binary sources, AGNs, blazars, X
ray novae, X
ray flares on stars,
ray transients, X
ray flashes etc

the use of LE tel
escopes will allow these objects to be detected and studied by
sky patrol monitoring

Discussion LE X
ray Telescopes

Results of analyses and simulations of lobster
eye X
ray telescopes have
indicated that they will be able to monitor the X

sky at an
unprecedented level
of sensitivity
, an order of magnitude better than any previous X
ray all

Limits as faint as 10
erg cm


for daily observation in soft X
ray range are
expected to be achieved, allowing monitoring of all cl
asses of X
ray sources, not
only X
ray binaries, but also fainter classes such as AGNs, coronal sources,
cataclysmic variables, as well as fast X
ray transients including gamma
bursts and the nearby type II supernovae.

For pointed observations, lim
its better than 10

erg sec

(0.5 to 3 keV)
could be obtained, sufficient enough to detect X
ray afterglows to GRBs.

The first prototypes of both Schmidt as well as Angel arrangements have been
produced succesfully for the first time, demonstratin
g the possibility to construct
these lenses by innovative but feasible technologies.

This makes the proposals for space projects with very wide field lobster eye
optics possible.

Feasibility of Independent Optical Searches

The recent detection of opti
cal afterglows and optical transients of gamma ray
bursts allows considering optical ground
based independent detection of these

The optical surveys achieving lim mag better than 19...23 for stars and/or 10 for
1 min exposures may detect OAs an
d OTs of GRBs

This opens the possibility of independent optical searches

These searches must be of
large field of view

i.e. CCD surveys and/or deep
patrol plates are suitable

The rate of OAs

estimated beaming


it is expected that sources emit

from which the gamma ray emission is
more beamed than the subsequent optical afterglow radiation due to the
deceleration of the jet by the ambient gas and the corresponding decline in its
relativistic beaming with time (Rhoads 1997)


because the shift
to lower frequencies accompanies the shift to lower bulk
Lorentz factor, the minimum solid angle into which the transient can radiate
increases with time


a jet geometry hence implies a higher rate of OAs detections


if bursts are highly collimated, the ga
mma rays will radiate into a small solid
angle, the optical light into a larger one, and radio into a still larger one


if bursts emit isotropically, we do not expect OAs unaccompanied by GRBs


the ratio of transients detected hence allows the ratio of th
e mean solid angle
into which transients radiate to be estimated


the GRBs rate known already


the OA rate with characteristics typical for the observed OAs can be estimated
by present and future sky survey programs

The estimated beaming for the OAs obser
ved so far

Recently, the evidence for collimation in GRBs has grown:


㸠〮0ㄠ景爠㤷〵〸⁓ 物⁥琠慬⸠ㄹ㤹

㰠‰⸰ ㌠景爠㤸〵ㄹ⁈3汰敲渠整⁡氮‱ 㤹

㰠‰⸰ ⁦ 爠r㤰ㄲ㌠An摥d獯渠整⁡氮‱ 㤹ⰠK畬歡牮椠整⁡氮‱㤹9

㰠‰⸰ ㌠景爠㤹〵㄰⁈3牲楳潮⁥琠慬 ‱ 㤹

The strongest evidence for collimation is in the brightest sources

This evidence is based on the observed profiles of the light curves

slopes and even breaks in the slope as a collimated flow slows and spreads

the number of optically

selected OAs could be greater than the number of
ray selected GRBs by a factor of (


where the go is the initial
Lorentz factor, the initial gamma
ray emission is beamed to an angle of about


and the afterglow emission is produced when the fireball has been
decelerated to a modest Lorentz factor


since typical bursts have



than 10
(e.g. Fenimore et al. 1993, Woods and
Loeb 1995) while the optical afterglow emission occurs at


nearly 10
, hence
this could boost the expected OAs rates by up to four orders of magnitude (we
will call this boosting factor)

The estimat
ed rates of OAs and OTs in real experiments

The recent digitization of deep sky patrol plates as well as CCD surveys provide
valuable input data for these searches.

Optical Transients (prompt emission)


observed rate of GRBs (by BATSE) is about 1 GRB/day


beaming factor 1 … 10 (no more since the time after GRB is small)


boosting factor of 1 … 100


actual GRB fraction with OTs 0.01

1 (brighter than mag 12)


estimated OT rate 0.01

100 OTs/day for the whole sky sphere


this means 2.5 x 10

…. 2.5 x 10



examples: astrograph plate (100 deg
) 2.5 x 10

… 2.5 x 10

OTs per plate

Optical Afterglows (delayed emission)


observed rate of GRBs (by BATSE) is about 1 GRB/day


beaming factor 1 … 100


boosting factor of 1 … 10 000


actual GRB fractio
n with OAs 0.5 (brighter than mag 23) and/or 0.05 (brighter
than mag 18)


estimated OA rate 0.5 … 5 000 OAs/day for the whole sky sphere lim mag 23


or 0.05 … 500 OAs/day for the whole sphere lim mag 18


this means 1 x 10

…. 1 x 10


lim mag 23 and 1
x 10

… 1 x 10

lim mag


not in contrast with results obtained by plate searches


Example: UKSTU plate area of 41 deg

23 mag limit ... 4 x 10
... 4 objects per plate

18 mag limit ... 4 x 10

.. 4 x 10

objects per plate


Constraints from observations (Schmidt 1999, Hudec 1999) < 0.15
events/square degree lim mag 23 i.e. boosting factor < 10 000


Note however that the background by SNe, variable AGNs, variable stars, flare
stars etc is higher
! Depending on galactic latitude, their integrated rate may
achieve ~ 1 000 to 5 000 variable objects per UKSTU plate, lim mag 23.

Conclusion astronomical plates/surveys

It seems to be feasible that both flaring (OTs) as well as fading (OAs) optical
ission related to GRBs may be detected by optical sky patrols. Although the
true rate of these triggers remains unknown, in is very probably that their rate is
substantially below the background rate, hence the good knowledge of all
background triggers mus
t be available as well as a reliable technique for their
classification and elimination.


false events not related to GRBs but with similar transient behavior

Background sources:


AGN flares/brightening

Stellar flares

Variable Stars

OTs of

unknown nature and origin

Nonastrophysical triggers


The supernovae, especially those of Ia type, may represent an important source
of confusion due their occurrence rates, rise and decay timescales, and

The expected rate of occur
rence for faint events (down to R 23 mag) is roughly 2

or 0.0015 arcmin

(Evans et al. 1989, Pain 1996, Brainerd 1998).

But, at least some, SNe may be probably related to GRBs (SN 1998bw and

AGN flares

Typical flare amplitude
s are between 0.5 and 1.3 mag, depending on the AGN
type (Smith A. G. Bl. Cont. Var. ASP Conf Ser 110, 1996, 3)

These are mean values. The spread of particular flare amplitudes is large (0.1
…. 6.7 mag).

Recently, there is growing evidence for large ampl
itude ( more than 10 mag)
flares on AGNs.

AGNs/QSOs surface densities: ~ 20 deg
2 lim mag B/V 20 (Iovino A. et al.
A&ASS 119(1996), 265
269, Hartwick F. D. A. and Scade D. ARA&A 28(1990),
437, Boyle et al. 1988), ~ 100 deg
2 lim mag B 22.5 (Trevese D. et
al. AJ
98(1989), 108), most of them variable (Trevese D. and Kron R.G. 1994 in Multi
Wavelength Continuum Emission of AGNs, 412 (Eds. T. Courvoisier and A.

Stellar flares

There is growing evidence for large amplitude (5 mag and more) stellar flar

archival searches have revealed large
amplitude flares (5
9 mag) from
otherwise typical dMe flare stars

rate of analogous stellar flares unknown

Variable stars

Also variable stars may exhibit light behavior similar to OAs and OTs.

Variable stars a
re observed more commonly in decline than in increase since
the declines are typically more slowly such as delta Cep stars, U Gem stars,
flare stars, novae etc.

Example: Y Dra Mira type variable inside GRB910709 detected and positioned
by COMPTEL: light v
ariations between 6 and 15 mag, gradual light decrease
after maximum (period 322 d).

Surface density: estimated rates for VS brighter than 20 mag:

80 deg

for /bII/ < 20 deg

4 deg

for /bII/ > 40 deg

(Hudec and Wenzel A&ASS 120 (1996), C707

ut the discovery probability is ~0.1 (blinkmicroscope use)

No statistics for variable stars below 20 mag available (no systematic surveys)

OTs of unknown nature and origin

There are real OTs of unknown nature but of astrophysical origin detected both

on emulsions and CCDs. Examples (real CCD detections):

OT 970215:

real CCD detection, V 13 mag, nothing down 20 mag on the
position, amplitude more than 7 mag (Vidal
Saiz J. et al., IBVS Budapest 4324,

OT 950806:
real object: detected on 20 CCD fr
ames, peak magnitude I 7.5,
amplitude more than 10 mag, nothing down mag 21 48 hrs after detection (Toth
I. et al. AA 315, 153, 1996).

OT triggers found by SNe searches (Schmidt et al. 1999, private

mystery events found at a rate of about
0.15 deg
/per time scale (between 10
min and 3 days) lim mag R 23.5. In 3 cases, no host galaxy seen down mag R
24, in 1 case, host galaxy clearly visible. 2 events at a low galactic latitude and
hence can be flare stars.

note that SN searches reject eve
nts with timescales less than 3 min (as cosmic
rays) hence can detect OAs but not all OTs

these searches are very limited so far (6 SN runs done, 2
6 sq. deg. per run,
Schmidt et al, 1999 private comm.)

The SN versus OAs rates


cosmological GRBs are much
rarer than SNe (10

to 10

times, Woods and Loeb


the GRB afterglows are however at peak luminosity 10

to 10

brighter than
SNeII (Woods and Loeb 1999)


in Euclidean space, this implies that GRBs are detected from a volume bigger
by a factor of abou
t (10

= 10
, roughly canceling the factor by which they are
rarer than Sne


the average detection rate of SNe and OAs may be comparable at lim mag
brighter than mag 18
20 in all colors (U, B, R, K) (Woods and Loeb 1998),
assuming the OAs frequency the

same as of gamma ray selected GRBs


if true, this has a significant consequence: in optical searches down to lim mag
20, the roughly identical numbers of SNe and of OAs are expected


this means that the OAs may be among detected SNe (Hudcov

et al. th

How to distinguish OAs and SNe (and other background


Light curve


Peak luminosity (only for objects with known redshift)


Color information

The color indices of the optical afterglows (OAs) of the GRBs

Powerful tool to searc
h for the common properties of these events

Important parameter reflecting the related physical processes

Specific color indices of OAs give a hope to resolve whether the optical event
is related to GRB even without available gamma
ray detection

arch for interrelations among the colors, luminosities and the decay rates of
the OAs (if

is known)

Results of study of colors of OAs

The color variations ((V
, (R
, (B
) during the decline of OAs are
for 0.8 days < t

< 10 days (
Šimon et al. 2001)

The colors of OAs on the final decline branch
concentrate at (V

0.25, (R
0.25, (B


(but large scatter of (U
) very
smooth shape of spectrum of OAs, no bumps or strong lines within the
ed I to B passbands. Slope of the spectrum can be supposed to be
almost constant and may have a powerlaw shape


楮⁴桩猠 灥p瑲慬⁲ 杩潮⸠

Concentration of the color indices the intrinsic reddening (in their host
galaxies) must be
quite similar

for all these OAs (rather small) these
GRBs are unlikely to come directly from the inner parts of th
e star
regions (maybe on our side of a star
forming region)


the recent results of OAs and OTs searches indicate that GRBs may be
monitored and studied by observing their optical emissions, i.e.
on satellite projec

the rate of OAs may be (significantly)
higher than the rate of GRBs

due to
different beaming

it is feasible to use
ground based optical devices

to monitor OAs and OTs of

this opens a
new observing window for GRBs

these surveys must be of
field and high sensitivity

there is however a
background of false triggers

(not related to GRBs but with
similar transient behavior) with poorly known statistics (for faint magnitudes)

this background is due to supernovae, AGN/QSOs, stellar flares, var
stars, optical transients of unknown origin and non
astrophysical triggers

the expected total number of optically variable sources of astrophysical origin
is large: ~ (0.5
2) in a 5 x 5 arcmin error box, depending on galactic latitude, lim
mag 23

(Hudec, 1999)

the recent searches (e.g. SN searches) and databases (e.g. UKSTU plate
collection) may be used to detect OAs

there even may be unrecognized OAs
in detected SNe

the detected OAs and especially OTs (since they will be recorded only once
ue to their short duration in most cases) must be further studied in detail to
eliminate them from background triggers

Suitable devices/methods

OMC (Optical Monitoring Camera) INTEGRAL: 5 x 5 deg
, lim mag 19

CCD based devices and telescopes (ASPA, ROTS

Digitized plate surveys

Digitized deep archival plates (e.g. UKSTU plate collection, Siding Springs
Schmidt, 17 000 plates with lim mag 20
23, different filters/colors)


The investigations of gamma
ray bursts and optic
al transients are supported by
the project KONTAKT ES002 provided by the Ministry of Education and Youth of
the Czech Republic and by the grant 205/99/0145 provided by the Grant Agency of
the Czech Republic. The investigation of plate defects has been supp
orted by the
Academic Link between the University of Westminster and Astronomical Institute
Ondrejov provided by the British Council in Prague.


Anderson M. I. 1999 Nature, 398, 400

Fenimore E. F., Epstein R. I. and Ho C. 1993, AAS

97, 59

Dahlen T. and Fransson C. 1999, preprint astro
ph/9905201, AA in press

Halpern J. P., Kemp J., Piran T. and Bershady M. A. 1999, ApJ 517, L105

Harrison F. A. et al. 1999 ApJ in press, astro

Hjorth J. et al., 1999, GCN 403

Kulkarni S. et
al. 1999 Nature 398, 389

Pain R. et al. 1996 ApJ 473, 356

Protheroe R. J. and Bednarek W., 1999, astro
ph/9904279, Astropart. Phys., accepted.

Reichart D. E., 1999, ApJ 521, 111

Rhoads J. E. 1997, ApJ 487, L1.

Sari R., Piran T. and Halpern J. P. 1999 A
pJ 519, L17

Woods E. and Loeb A. 1995, ApJ 453, 583

Woods E. and Loeb A. 1998 ApJ 508, 760.

Hudec R. 1993 Astroph. Letters and Communications 28, 359

Park H. S. et al. 1997 ApJ 490, 99

Williams G. G. et al. 4th GRB Huntsville Conference, 837

Akerlof C. K.

and McKay 1999

Hudec R. Astroph. Lett. Comm., 1993

Hudec R. and Wenzel W. AA, 1997

Gorosabel J. U. 1999 Dissertation

Bloom J. S. et al. 1999 astro
ph/9905301 Nature March 23 1999

Kehoe R. et al., 1999, astro