I f St d di ti f 20943 6 Issues for Standardization of 20943-6: Procedure for the Specification of Web Ontology

grotesqueoperationInternet and Web Development

Oct 21, 2013 (4 years and 19 days ago)

119 views

Stud
y
Period Meetin
g
on
yg
ROR/ODMS/PSO & SQL/MM-8 MDR
IfStdditif20943
6
I
ssues
f
or
St
an
d
ar
di
za
ti
on o
f

20943
-
6
:
Procedure for the Specification of Web Ontology
State Key Laboratory for Software Engineering (SKLSEI),
WuhanUniversityWuhanChinaAugust21
222009
Wuhan

University
,
Wuhan
,
China
,
August

21
-
22
,
2009
Doo
KwonBaikJeong
DongKimandDongwonJeong
Doo
-
Kwon

Baik
,
Jeong
-
Dong

Kim
,
and

Dongwon

Jeong
{baikdk, kjdhu}@korea.ac.kr
, djeong@kunsan.ac.kr
Korea University, Kunsan National University
Contents
Introduction to 20943-6: PSO

Motivation

Purposes

Scope

ConceptualModel
Conceptual

Model
Issues




2
Study Period Meeting on ROR/ODMS/PSO & SQL/MM-8 MDR
Discussion History
The idea of this proposal has been presented in the following
meetings
meetings
ISO/IEC JTC 1/ SC 32 Workshop (September2008, China)
ISO/IEC JTC 1/ SC 32 Workshop on ROR

ODMS-SMMP Study Period
※ WG2 N1177: “Extending the Metadata Registry for Semantic Web"
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32/WG2 Interim Meeting
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32/ WG2 Interim (November 2008, Portugal)
※WG2 N1219: "Extending the Metadata Registry for Semantic Web“
Subtitle: PSO: Procedure for the Specification of Web Ontology (based on MDR)
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32/WG2 Plenary Meeting

均WNㄲ㠳却pPupEt摩瑨䵄MrStuWn
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 Plenaly (July 2009, Korea)
3

WG2

N1283
:
St
u
d
y
P
re
i
o
d
on
E
x
t
en
di
ng
th
e
MDR

f
or
S
eman
ti
c
W
e
b
Project Subdivision 20943-6: Procedure for the Specification of Web Ontology
Study Period Meeting on ROR/ODMS/PSO & SQL/MM-8 MDR
Motivation
MDR

providesagoodintroductiontometadataconceptsincludingalotof

provides

a

good

introduction

to

metadata

concepts
,
including

a

lot

of

insight into certain aspects of the granularity of metadata

MDR contributes knowledge integrity in a large scale
Thesimplicityprovidestheorganizationofimplementaladaptation

The

simplicity

provides

the

organization

of

implemental

adaptation
–The representational simplicity allows for easy sharing of metadata

In a word, MDR contains standardized conceptsfor various applications
fild
fi
e
ld
s
Semantic Web
p
romotes structured metadata re
p
resentation
,

pp,
such as an ontology schema that data concepts are associated
via relationships

﹧ョﱯ﹣沈ﱹ﹥﹤



﹧

ョﱯ

﹣





﹥





ﱡョ殺ﱩ﹫﹣
4
Study Period Meeting on ROR/ODMS/PSO & SQL/MM-8 MDR
Motivation (cont.)
Under such a situation, we can use the standardized concepts in
MDRforbuildingOntology
MDR

for

building

Ontology
Need to s
p
ecif
y
Ontolo
gy
usin
g
standardized conce
p
ts in
pygygp
MDR for the Semantic Web
However, there is no standard for specifying Ontology using
conce
p
ts in a re
g
istr
y
pgy
The Goal of this proposal is to provide the specification support of
Ontologsingtheconceptsinaregistr
Ontolog
y u
sing

the

concepts

in

a

registr
y
5
Study Period Meeting on ROR/ODMS/PSO & SQL/MM-8 MDR
Purposes
The purposes of this 20943-6 are to promote the
followings:
followings:

Ease of definitionof Ontology schema

CreationofOntologyschemaconsistingofstandardizedconcepts
Creation

of

Ontology

schema

consisting

of

standardized

concepts
–i.e., well-known concepts or generalized concepts, which are
accepted by general users as well as domain experts

ﵭョ﹤﹧イョ
﹤葉

ﵭョ

﹤﹧



イ



﹣



﹤葉

北說︠

More formalized specification of ontolo
gy
gy
6
Study Period Meeting on ROR/ODMS/PSO & SQL/MM-8 MDR
Scope
The scope of 20943-6 covers procedures for the
specificationofOntologybasedonISO/IEC11179
specification

of

Ontology

based

on

ISO/IEC

11179
This part of 20943-6 will use standardized concepts
registeredandmanagedinMDRtospecifyOntologies
registered

and

managed

in

MDR

to

specify

Ontologies
.
This part currently consists of the following clauses:


:FrameworkforOntologySpecification




:

Framework

for

Ontology

Specification

Clause 2: Mapping Model between MDR and Ontology

Clause 3: Procedure for Ontology Specification
This proposal does not contain

A Ontology building methods by a specific ontology description
lhRDFRDF
SOWLTiMKIF
l
anguage, suc
h
as
RDF
,
RDF
-
S
,
OWL
,
T
op
i
c
M
aps,
KIF
,
and so on
7
Study Period Meeting on ROR/ODMS/PSO & SQL/MM-8 MDR
Conceptual Model
MtdtRit
Ontology
M
e
t
a
d
a
t
a
R
eg
i
s
t
ry
(ISO/IEC 11179)
DEC
CD
OC
Ontology
realize
DE
VD
. . .
MDRs
(Sets of concepts)
realize
created
(specified)
(specified)
Our Proposal
Our Proposal
utilize
EDR
(Environmental Data
caDSR
(US National
METeOR
(Metadata Online
Process Mana
g
e
r
Registry)
Cancer Institute)
Registry)
g
Mapping Info. and Rulus
8
Study Period Meeting on ROR/ODMS/PSO & SQL/MM-8 MDR
8
Conceptual Model (cont.)
Domain
Ran
g
e
CtLl
Property
Type
Type
Property
Property
g
Type
Relation
Property
Type
Type
Property
Property
Type
Class
Class
Semantic Web Level
Instance Level
C
oncep
t

L
eve
l
Proposal (PSO, Procedure for the Specification of Web Ontology)
PSOLevel
DEC_Relationship
Concept
PSO

Level
DEC
Object Class
+
Concept_Relationship
Concept
CD_Relationship
CD
Conceptual Level
Conceptual Level
Representational Level
Property
VD_Relationship
VD
DE
MDR Level
Representational Level
Datatype
Unit of Measure
Study Period Meeting on ROR/ODMS/PSO & SQL/MM-8 MDR
9
Issues for Standardization of PSO
We first need to consider the following issues

DfiiMiRltibttfMDRd

D
e
fi
n
i
ng
M
app
i
ng
R
e
l
a
ti
on
b
e
t
ween componen
t
s o
f

MDR
an
d

Ontology

Definition of
p
rocesses for s
p
ecification
pp
–Class Property Relation

WhCdiCt

W
e
h
ave
C
ana
di
an
C
ommen
t
s

Input date: August 13, 2009
10
Study Period Meeting on ROR/ODMS/PSO & SQL/MM-8 MDR
Issues: Mapping Model
Mapping Model between MDR and Ontology

AnalyzesmappingrelationsbetweenOntologyandMDR

Analyzes

mapping

relations

between

Ontology

and

MDR
MDR Level
Web Ontology Level
Conceptual Domain
Data Element Concept
Object Class
Pro
p
ert
y
Concept (Class)
Property
Data Element
Data Type
py
Relation
Value Domain
Relationship
Relation
11
Study Period Meeting on ROR/ODMS/PSO & SQL/MM-8 MDR
Issues: Specification Process
We need to define formal specification steps

Thispartcontainstheoverallprocessforbuildingontologyanddevelops

This

part

contains

the

overall

process

for

building

ontology
,
and

develops

and defines concrete/detailed operations of each process.
repeat
repeat
repeat
Define
Concept
Define
Define
conceptproperty
Concept
(Class)
Properties
Relations
12
Study Period Meeting on ROR/ODMS/PSO & SQL/MM-8 MDR
Issues: Canadian Comments
The summary of the comments is as follows

Referneces

Referneces

Scope

Title

Some minors

Details:OriginalDocument

Details:

Original

Document

WG2_N1291-Canadian-Position-on-Procedure-for-specification-of-web-
ontology
13
Study Period Meeting on ROR/ODMS/PSO & SQL/MM-8 MDR
Q/A
Thk !
Th
an
k
you
!
Doo-Kwon Baik (baikdk@korea.ac.kr
)
Jeong-Dong Kim (kjdfu@korea.ac.kr
)
Dongwon Jeong (
djeong@kunsanackr
)
14
Dongwon Jeong (
djeong@kunsan
.
ac
.
kr
)
Study Period Meeting on ROR/ODMS/PSO & SQL/MM-8 MDR