EVALUATION OF CARCINOGENIC EFFECTS OF ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS (EMF)

capricioustelephoneUrban and Civil

Nov 16, 2013 (3 years and 8 months ago)

89 views

 !"#$%#&'!()#%*&!+& %"$,&-./$,%*&",$.#,."&01213&21&4567&089:091
￿
Abstract
;& <&=>?=@A<&@B&CDEA&AC>FG&HIA&C@&EJK<ACELIC<&CD<&MI?MEJ@L<JEM&<N&<MCA&@B&<O<MC?@:
PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFA&@J&D>PIJR&;& <?<&I?<&PIJG&<N&<MCA&@B&<O<MC?@PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFA&@J&
D>PIJ&A>MD&IA&MIJM<?S&<=EF<PE@O@LGS&IM>C<&IJF&MD?@JEM&<N&<MCAR&;& <A<&<N&<MCA&KI?G&
IMM@?FEJL&C@&CD<&Q&<OF&AC?<JLCD&IJF&<JKE?@JP<JCIO&M@JFECE@JAR&;& <?<&DIK<&T<<J&
PIJG&EJACIJM<A&@B&DI?PB>O&<N&<MCA&@B&<O<MC?@PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFA&B?@P&A>MD&A<<PEJLOG&
EJJ@M>@>A&F<KEM<A&IA&P@TEO<&=D@J<AS&M@P=>C<?AS&=@H<?&OEJ<A&IJF&F@P<ACEM&HE?:
EJLR&;& <&TIOIJM<&@B&<=EF<PE@O@LEM&<KEF<JM<&EJFEMIC<A&CDIC&P@TEO<&=D@J<&>A<&@B&
O<AA&CDIJ&&G<I?A&F@<A&J@C&=@A<&IJG&EJM?<IA<F&?EAW&@B&T?IEJ&C>P@>?&@?&IM@>ACEM&
J<>?@PIR&+@?&O@JL:C<?P&>A<S&FICI&I?<&A=I?A<S&IJF&CD<&B@OO@HEJL&M@JMO>AE@JA&I?<&
CD<?<B@?<&>JM<?CIEJ&IJF&C<JCICEK<R
X.Y&Z!)/"7&<O<MC?@PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFS&MIJM<?
EVALUATION OF
CARCINOGENIC EFFECTS
OF ELECTROMAGNETIC
FIELDS (EMF)
Vahdettin Bayazit
1
*, Banu Bayram
1
,
Zeydin Pala
2
, Ozkan Atan
3
￿ &/<=I?CP<JC&@B& E@O@LGS&+IM>OCG&@B&%?CA&IJF&"ME<JM<AS&
->A&%O=I?AOIJ&(JEK<?AECGS&S&->AS]>?W<G
￿ &/<=I?CP<JC&@B&.O<MC?@JEM&IJF&%>C@PICE@JS&^@MICE@JIO&"MD@@OS&
->A&%O=I?AOIJ&(JEK<?AECG&S&S&->AS&]>?W<G
￿ &/<=I?CP<JC&@B&]<MDJEMIO&_?@L?IPAS&^@MICE@JIO&"MD@@OS&
Y>`>JM>GaO&(JEK<?AECGS&S^IJS&]>?W<G
e&&,@??<A=@JFEJL&I>CD@?
 !"#$%#&'!()#%*&!+& %"$,&-./$,%*&",$.#,."&01213&21&4567&08f:091
^%g/.]]$#& %Y%h$]&.]&%*R7&.^%*(%]$!#&!+&,%),$#!i.#$,&.++.,]"&!+&.*.,])!-%i#.]$,&+$.*/"&.-+
Introduction
$JC<?JICE@JIO& %L<JMG& B@?& )<A<I?MD& @J&,IJM<?& 4$%),6&
MOIAAEQ&MICE@J&@B&.lC?<P<OG&*@H&+?<m><JMG&4.*+6&PIL:
J<CEM&Q&<OFA&IA&n=@AAETOG&MI?MEJ@L<JEM&C@&D>PIJAo&EA&TIA<F&
>=@J&IOO&@B&CD<&IKIEOITO<&FICI&=?E@?&C@&IJF&EJMO>FEJL&&
4$%),S& 6R& i<J<?IOOGS& AC>FE<A& @B& CD<& <N& <MCA& @B&.*+&
Q&<OF&<l=@A>?<&@B&M<OOA&DIK<&AD@HJ&J@&EJF>MCE@J&@B&L<J@:
C@lEMECG&IC&Q&<OFA&T<O@H&&q]R&;& <&J@CITO<&<lM<=CE@J&EA&
<KEF<JM<&B?@P&?<M<JC&AC>FE<A&?<=@?CEJL&/#%&FIPIL<&IC&
Q&<OF&AC?<JLCDA&IA&O@H&IA&&μ]3&D@H<K<?S&CD<A<&AC>FE<A&
I?<&ACEOO&T<EJL&<KIO>IC<F&IJF&@>?&>JF<?ACIJFEJL&@B&CD<A<&
Q&JFEJLA& EA& EJM@P=O<C<& 4SS6R&;& <?<& EA& IOA@& EJM?<IAEJL&
<KEF<JM<& CDIC&.*+& PILJ<CEM& BE<OFA& PIG& EJC<?IMC& HECD&
/#%:FIPILEJL&IL<JCA&4S6R&;& <?<&EA&J@&MO<I?&<KEF<JM<&
@B&CD<&IMCEKICE@J&TG&.*+&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFA&@B&L<J<A&IAA@:
MEIC<F& HECD& CD<& M@JC?@O& @B& CD<& M<OO& MGMO<& 46R& g@H<K<?S&
AGAC<PICEM&AC>FE<A&IJIOGAEJL&CD<&?<A=@JA<&@B&CD<&HD@O<&
L<J@P<& DIK<& G<C& C@& T<& =<?B@?P<FR& -IJG& @CD<?& M<OO>:
OI?&AC>FE<AS&B@?&<lIP=O<&@J&M<OO&=?@OEB<?ICE@JS&I=@=C@AEAS&
MIOME>P&AELJIOOEJL&IJF&PIOELJIJC&C?IJAB@?PICE@JS&DIK<&
=?@F>M<F& EJM@JAEAC<JC& @?& EJM@JMO>AEK<&?<A>OCA& 4:6R
]D<?<& DIK<& T<<J& PIJG& AC>FE<A& A>LL<ACEJL& CDIC& <l=@:
A>?<&C@&H<IW&<O<MC?@PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFA&EA&IAA@MEIC<F&HECD&I&
APIOO&T>C&AELJEQ&MIJC&EJM?<IA<&EJ&CD<&?EAW&@B&L<CCEJL&MIJM<?&
4S6R&;& EA&M@>OF&T<&MI>A<F&TG&L<J<&P>CICE@JA&?<A>OC:
EJL&B?@P&/#%&FIPIL<R&%&L<J<&EA&I&A<MCE@J&@B&/#%&M@J:
CIEJEJL&CD<&EJB@?PICE@J&J<<F<F&C@&PIW<&I&=I?CEM>OI?&=?@:
C<EJ&@?&<J`GP<R&;& <?<&EA&IOA@&I&A<MCE@J&CDIC&MIJ&C>?J&CD<&
L<J<&@J&@?&@N& &EJ&?<A=@JA<&C@&@>CAEF<&AELJIOAR&;& <&L?@HCD&
@B& IJ& @?LIJEAP& B?@P& I& B<?CEOEA<F& <LL& EJK@OK<A& I& D>L<OG&
M@P=O<l&=ICC<?J&@B&AHECMDEJL&L<J<A&@J&IJF&@N& &CDIC&?<L:
>OIC<A&L?@HCDS&M<OO&FEKEAE@J&IJF&FEN& <?<JCEICE@J&EJC@&A=<:
MEQ&M&CEAA><AR&/#%&FIPIL<&MIJ&A@P<CEP<A&LEK<&>J?<L>:
OIC<F&L?@HCD&C@&B@?P&C>P@>?AR&g@H<K<?S&CD<&<N& <MC&PIG&
J@C&T<&EPP<FEIC<R&;& <&IN& <MC<F&M<OOA&A<<P&C@&L@&CD?@>LD&
A<K<?IO&ACIL<A&@B&<K<?&EJM?<IAEJL&L<J<CEM&IJF&P@O<M>OI?&
IJI?MDG& T<B@?<& CD<G& Q&JIOOG&?<IMD& CD<& =@EJC& @B& >JAC@=:
=ITO<&L?@HCD&IJF&FEKEAE@JR&ZD<J&IAA<AAEJL&IJG&MI?MEJ@:
L<JEM&<N& <MCA&@B&<O<MC?@PILJ<CEM&<l=@A>?<S&H<&P>AC&T<I?&
EJ&PEJF&CDIC&CD<?<&PIG&T<&I&AEPEOI?&F<OIGR&$C&PIG&T<&A@P<&
G<I?A&T<B@?<&H<&WJ@H&CD<&B>OO&MI?MEJ@L<JEM&<N& <MCA&@B&CD<&
?<M<JC& <l=O@AEK<& L?@HCD& EJ& CD<& >A<& @B& P@TEO<& =D@J<AR
Cancer and EMF
$J&C@CIOS&IT@>C&&=I=<?A&@B&@?ELEJIO&AC>FE<A&@J&P@TEO<&
=D@J<& >A<& IJF& MIJM<?& H<?<& =>TOEAD<F& EJ& CD<& OIAC& Q&K<&
G<I?AR& )<A>OCA& I?<& A>PPI?E`<F& EJ& ]ITO<& R& B@?& T?IEJ& C>:
P@>?A& IJF& EJ& ]ITO<& R& B@?& IM@>ACEM& J<>?@PIR& %OO& T>C&
@J<& AC>FG& H<?<& MIA<:M@JC?@O& AC>FE<AS& P@ACOG& @J& T?IEJ&
C>P@>?AS& A@P<& @J& AIOEKI?G& LOIJF& C>P@>?A& @?& >K>OI&
P<OIJ@PIR&!J<&HIA&I&OI?L<&M@D@?C&AC>FG&@B&IOO&/IJEAD&
P@TEO<&=D@J<&A>TAM?ET<?A&T<CH<<J&&IJF&&HD@&
H<?<&B@OO@H<F&>=&B@?&I&KI?E<CG&@B&MIJM<?A3&J@&EJM?<IA<F&
?EAW& B@?& IJG& MIJM<?& HIA& @TA<?K<F& T>C& B@OO@H& >=& CEP<&
HIA&AD@?C&46R&;& <&$JC<?=D@J<&AC>FG&EA&I&P>OCEJICE@JIO&
MIA<:M@JC?@O&AC>FG&M@@?FEJIC<F&TG&CD<&$%),R&$C&EA&I&=@=:
>OICE@J:TIA<F&AC>FG&HECD&=?@A=<MCEK<&IAM<?CIEJP<JC&@B&
EJMEF<JC&MIA<A&IJF&BIM<:C@:BIM<&EJC<?KE<HA&B@?&<l=@A>?<&
IAA<AAP<JCR&ZECD&?<LI?F&C@&T?IEJ&C>P@>?AS&?<A>OCA&B?@P&
CD<&Q&?AC&B@>?&M@P=@J<JCA&@B&CD<&$JC<?=D@J<&AC>FG&A>L:
Brain Tumours Brain Tumours Short Latency Brain Tumours Longer Latency
No. Exp. Cases
RR
16
estimate
(95%CI
17
)
No. Exp. Cases RR estimate (95%CI) No. Exp. Cases RR estimate (95%CI)
uv 2S1&41Su:2S86 uv 2S1&41Su:2S86&w2&G?58&2f
41S9:2S86w9&G?&
2S0&41Sf:0Sf6&w21&G?
ff 1Sv&41Sf:2S06 0v 2S2&41Sf:0S16&0:5&G?2u 1Su&41Su:2S86&x8G?
25y 1Sv&41Sf:2S26 92 2S1&41Sf:2Sf6&1S9:5&G?
98&
00
41Sf:2Sf6&x5&G?&
1Su&41S8:2S86&x9&G?
298 2S1&41Sv:2S26 vu 41Sy:2S56&2:8&G?08 2S1&41Su:2Sf6&w9&G?
81&IJIO@L><&
2f&FELECIO
2S5&41Sy:2Sv6
29&IJIO@L><&
22&FELECIO
41Su:0S16&
2:0&G?
2u&IJIO@L><&
2&FELECIO
2S9&41Sy:0S96&w0G?
2vv&IJIO@L><&
008&FELECIO
2S5&42S1:2Sf6&
2S1&41Sv:2S06
2vv&IJIO@L><&
008&FELECIO
42S1:2Sf6&w&2&G?&
2S1&41Sv:2S06&w2&G?
8f&IJIO@L><&
55&FELECIO
2S5&41Sv:0S56&w21&G?
&
1Sy&41Sf:2S96&w9&G?
028&LOE@PI&
22v&P<JEJLE@PI
1Sv&41Sf:2S16&
1Su&41S9:1Sy6
220&
f8
1Sv&41Sf:2S26&2:8&G?&
1Sf&41S8:1Sy6&2:8&G?
09&
20&
41S9:2S96&x21&G?&
1Sy&41S8:2Sy6&x21&G?
8u&O@H:L?IF<&LOE@PI&
9y&DELD:L?IF<&LOE@PI&
fu&P<JEJLE@PI
2S2&41Sf:0S16&
1Sf&41S8:1Sy6&
1Sv&41S9:2S56
2y&
08&
59
1Sy&41S8:2Sv6&2:8&G?&
1Sf&41S5:2S16&2:8&G?&
1Sv&41S9:2S56&2:8&G?
f&
v&
f
41S8:fS26&x21&G?&
1S9&41S0:2S56&x21&G?&
2S1&41S5:5S06&x21&G?
2f
&)):&)<OICEK<&)EAW&
2u
&,$:&,@JQ&F<JM<&$JC<?KIO
]% *.&2R&)<A>OCA&@B&<=EF<PE@O@LEMIO&AC>FE<A&@J&P@TEO<&=D@J<&>A<&IJF&T?IEJ&C>P@>?A&42yS0yS8fS8uS8v6R
 !"#$%#&'!()#%*&!+& %"$,&-./$,%*&",$.#,."&01213&21&4567&08u:091
^%g/.]]$#& %Y%h$]&.]&%*R7&.^%*(%]$!#&!+&,%),$#!i.#$,&.++.,]"&!+&.*.,])!-%i#.]$,&+$.*/"&.-+
L<AC&J@&?EAW&EJM?<IA<&B@?&P<JEJLE@PI&@?&LOE@PIR&;& EA&EA&
M@JAEAC<JCOG&A@&IP@JL&A>Tz<MCA&HECD&O<AA&CDIJ&&G<I?A&
@B& >A<R& +@?&?<L>OI?& P@TEO<& =D@J<& >A<?A& @B& & G<I?A& @?&
P@?<S&J@&EJFEMICE@JA&@B&?EAW&EJM?<IA<A&H<?<&A<<J&EJ&CD?<<&
@>C&@B&B@>?&M@P=@J<JCAS&JIP<OG&EJ&"H<F<JS&/<JPI?W&
IJF&CD<&(X&46&T>C&CD<&i<?PIJ&M@P=@J<JC&F@<A&A<<&
I& A@P<HDIC&?IEA<F&?<OICEK<&?EAW& <ACEPIC<& B@?& LOE@PI&
46R&;& EA&EJM?<IA<S&D@H<K<?S&EA&TIA<F&@J&APIOO&J>PT<?A&
IJF& F><& C@& CD<& HEF<& M@JBEF<JM<& EJC<?KIO& CD<&?<A>OC& EA&
J@C& EJ& M@JC?IFEMCE@J& HECD& CD<& @CD<?& $JC<?=D@J<& M@P:
=@J<JCAR& $J& M@JC?IACS& I&"H<FEAD& L?@>=& J@C& =I?CEME=IC:
EJL& EJ& CD<& $JC<?=D@J<:AC>FGS& M@JF>MCEJL& A<K<?IO& MIA<:
M@JC?@O&AC>FE<A&>AEJL&A<OB:IFPEJEAC<?<F&m><ACE@JJIE?<A&
B@?& <l=@A>?<& IAA<AAP<JCS& DIA&?<=<IC<FOG& @TA<?K<F& EJ:
M?<IA<F&?<OICEK<&?EAW& <ACEPIC<A& B@?& T?IEJ& C>P@>?A& IJF&
EA& CD<& @JOG& L?@>=& CDIC& @TA<?K<F& A>MD& IJ& EJM?<IA<& IO:
?<IFG&IBC<?&B<H&G<I?A&@B&>A<&@B&I&P@TEO<&=D@J<&4S6R
%M@>ACEM&J<>?@PIAS&T<JELJ&C>P@>?A&CDIC&F<K<O@=&K<?G&
AO@HOGS&I?EA<&B?@P&CD<&"MDHIJJ&M<OOAS&HDEMD&<JB@OF&CD<&
K<ACET>O@M@MDO<I?&J<?K<R&;& <G&I?<&@B&=I?CEM>OI?&EJC<?<AC&
T<MI>A<&@B&CD<E?&O@MICE@JR&;& <&gI?F<OO:L?@>=&B?@P&"H<:
F<J& DIA& EJ& A<K<?IO& AC>FE<A&?<=@?C<F&?IEA<F&?<OICEK<&?EAW&
<ACEPIC<A&B@?&IM@>ACEM&J<>?@PI&IJF&IOA@&HECD&K<?G&AD@?C&
EJF>MCE@J&=<?E@FA&46R&]H@&@B&CD<&$JC<?=D@J<&M@P=@:
J<JCAS&/<JPI?W&IJF&"H<F<JS&DIK<&?<=@?C<F&CD<E?&M@>J:
C?G&A=<MEQ&M&IM@>ACEM&J<>?@PI&?<A>OCA&4S6R&*{JJ&<C&IOR&
?<=@?C<F&I&F@>TOEJL&@B&CD<&?<OICEK<&?EAW&<ACEPIC<&IBC<?&C<J&
G<I?A&@B&?<L>OI?&P@TEO<&=D@J<&>A<&M@P=I?<F&C@&A>Tz<MCA&
HD@&J<K<?&>A<F&I&P@TEO<&=D@J<&?<L>OI?OGR&;& EA&IAA@MEI:
CE@J&T<MIP<&AC?@JL<?&HD<J&CD<&IJIOGAEA&HIA&?<AC?EMC<F&
C@&=?<B<??<F&=D@J<&>A<&IC&CD<&AIP<&AEF<&IA&CD<&C>P@>?R&
,D?EAC<JA<J|A&?<A>OC& FEF& J@C& A>==@?C& CDEAS& T>C& EC& HIA&
TIA<F&@J&B<H<?&O@JL:C<?P&>A<?AR&"El&@B&CDE?C<<J&M@P=@:
J<JCA&@B&$JC<?=D@J<&4EJMO>FEJL&"H<F<J&IJF&/<JPI?W6&
H<?<&=@@O<F&B@?&I&z@EJC&IJIOGAEA&C@&<lIPEJ<&CD<&IAA@MEI:
CE@J&T<CH<<J&P@TEO<&=D@J<&>A<&IJF&?EAW&@B&IM@>ACEM&J<>:
?@PI&46R&ZDEO<&J@&@K<?IOO&IAA@MEICE@J&HIA&A<<J&IP@JL&
IOO&O@JL:C<?P&>A<?AS&CD<&FICI&A>LL<AC&CDIC&CD<?<&PIG&T<&
IJ&EJM?<IA<F&?EAW&HD<J&CD<&=?<B<??<F&AEF<&@B&CD<&D<IF&@B&
>A<&EA&M@JAEF<?<F&EJ&CD<&IJIOGAEAR&+@?&}&G<I?A&@B&>A<&@B&
P@TEO<& =D@J<AS& CD<&?<OICEK<&?EAW& B@?& IM@>ACEM& J<>?@PI&
IC&CD<&=?<B<??<F&AEF<&@B&>A<&HIA&SR& <MI>A<&@B&P<CD@F:
@O@LEMIO&FEN& <?<JM<A&T<CH<<J&AC>FE<AS&EC&H@>OF&DIK<&T<<J&
@B& M@JAEF<?ITO<& EJC<?<AC& C@& M@P=I?<& CD<&?<A>OCA& IM?@AA&
CD<&AEl&AC>FE<AS&T>C&APIOO&J>PT<?A&EJ&P@AC&@B&CD<&M<JC?<A&
=?<MO>F<&CDIC&IJIOGAEAR&g@H<K<?S&EJ&IJ&ICC<P=C&C@&A<=I:
?IC<&CD<&<N& <MC&EJ&CD<&B@>?&IFFECE@JIO&AC>FE<AS&CD<&/IJEAD&
IJF&CD<&"H<FEAD&AC>FE<A&H<?<&<lMO>F<F&B?@P&CD<&=@@O:
EJLS&HDEMD&?<A>OC<F&EJ&IJ&EJM?<IA<&@B&CD<&=@@O<F&?<OICEK<&
?EAW&<ACEPIC<R&;& EA&EJFEMIC<A&CDIC&CD<&IAA@MEICE@J&A<<J&TG&
"MD@<PIW<?& HIA& J@C& @JOG& F?EK<J& TG& CD<&"H<FEAD& FICIR&
%OO&CD@A<&AC>FE<A&I?<&BIMEJL&OEPECICE@JA&EJ&CD<E?&<l=@A>?<&
IAA<AAP<JCS&HDEMD&HIA&<ECD<?&I&OEAC&@B&A>TAM?ET<?A&B?@P&
CD<&@=<?IC@?A&@?&A<OB:?<=@?C<F&P@TEO<&=D@J<&>A<R&ZDEO<&
CD<& Q&?AC& P<CD@F& EA& IJ& @Tz<MCEK<& P<IA>?<S& EC& DIA& OEPECI:
CE@JA& T<MI>A<& A>TAM?E=CE@J& =?<FEMCA& >A<& @B& I& P@TEO<&
=D@J<& @JOG& C@& A@P<& <lC<JCR& )<M<JC& KIOEFICE@J& AC>FE<A&
EJ&K@O>JC<<?A&M@P=I?EJL&M>??<JC&A<OB:?<=@?C<F&>A<&HECD&
C?I~&&M&?<M@?FA&B?@P&J<CH@?W&@=<?IC@?A&AD@H&I&P@F<?:
IC<& IL?<<P<JCS& T>C& EC& MIJJ@C& T<& <lMO>F<F& CDIC& IL?<<:
P<JC&EA&H@?A<&HECD&?<A=<MC&C@&=IAC&P@TEO<&=D@J<&>A<&@?&
IP@JL&=ICE<JCA&HECD&T?IEJ&C>P@>?AR&.A=<MEIOOG&=ICE<JCA&
HECD& DELD& ACIL<& LOE@PI& AD@H<F& A@P<& P<P@?G& =<?B@?:
PIJM<&=?@TO<PA&EJ&CD<&/IJEAD&$JC<?=D@J<&AC>FG&46R&
,DEOFD@@F& T?IEJ& MIJM<?& AC>FE<A& DIK<& AD@HJ& EJM@JAEA:
C<JC&?<A>OCAR&%A&HECD&MDEOFD@@F&O<>WI<PEIS&I&=@@O<F&IJIO:
GAEA& @B& MDEOFD@@F& T?IEJ& MIJM<?& AC>FE<A& AD@>OF& T<& K<?G&
EJB@?PICEK<&IJF&EA&CD<?<B@?<&?<M@PP<JF<FR&%&=@@O<F&
IJIOGAEA&@B&CDEA&WEJF&MIJ&EJ<l=<JAEK<OG&=?@KEF<&I&L?<IC<?&
IJF&EP=?@K<F&EJAELDC&EJC@&CD<&<lEACEJL&FICIS&EJMO>FEJL&
CD<& =@AAETEOECG& @B& A<O<MCE@J& TEIA& IJFS& EB& CD<& AC>FE<A& I?<&
Acoustic Neuroma Acoustic Neuroma Short Latency Acoustic Neuroma Longer Latency
No. Exp. Cases RR
18
(95%CI
19
) No. Exp. Cases RR (95%CI) No. Exp. Cases RR (95%CI)
9 1Sv&41S2:8S06
00 2S1&41S9:2Sy6 v 2Sv41Su:8S96&1S9:0&G?9 2Sy&41Sf:9Sy6
u 1Sf&41S5:2S56
u 1S9&41S0:2S56&2:0&G?22 2Su&41S9:9S26&5:f&G?
5ve&IJIO@L><&
05e&FELECIO
5S9&42Sv:fSv6&
41Su:0S06
20e&IJIO@L><&
02eFELECIO
5S1&42S1:yS56&2:9&G?&
2S0&41Sf:0S06&2:9&G?
ue&IJIO@L><&
0e&FELECIO
5S9&41Su:2fSv6&w21&G?&
0S1&41S0:00S26&w9&G?
vy 41Sf:2S96 88 1Sv&41S9:2S56&2:8&G?& 28 2Sy&41Sy:8S26&x21&G?&
89 1Sy&41S9:2Sf6& 05 1Sy&41S9:2Sf6&2:8&G?0 41S1:2S26&x21&G?&
01&IJIO@L><&
95&FELECIO
8S0&42Sv:216&0S1&
42S1:5Sv6&
0&IJIO@L><&
0y&FELECIO
ySy&42S8:fy6&2:9&G?&
2Su&41Sy:5S96&G?&
22&IJIO@L><&
u&IJIO@L><&
05&FELECIO
9S2&42Sy:286&9:21&G?&
0Sf&41Sy:vS16&w21&G?&
0Su&42S5:9Su6&9:21&G?
5f1 1Sy&41Su:2S26 2u8
1Sv&41Su:2S16&
2S9:8&G?&
25y&
8u
1Sy&41Su:2S06&9:y&G?&
41Su:2S96&x21&G?
e&/EAM@?FIJC&=IE?A&
2v
&)):&)<OICEK<&)EAW&
2y
&,$:&,@JQ&F<JM<&$JC<?KIO
]% *.&0R&)<A>OCA&@B&<=EF<PE@O@LEMIO&AC>FE<A&@J&P@TEO<&=D@J<&>A<&IJF&IM@>ACEM&J<>?@PI&42fS&2vS&2yS&00S&89S&8fS&8u6
 !"#$%#&'!()#%*&!+& %"$,&-./$,%*&",$.#,."&01213&21&4567&08v:091
^%g/.]]$#& %Y%h$]&.]&%*R7&.^%*(%]$!#&!+&,%),$#!i.#$,&.++.,]"&!+&.*.,])!-%i#.]$,&+$.*/"&.-+
A>~&&ME<JCOG&D@P@L<J<@>AS&MIJ&@N& <?&CD<&T<AC&<ACEPIC<&@B&
?EAW&4S6R&+@?&IF>OC&T?<IAC&MIJM<?&P@?<&?<M<JC&AC>FE<A&
DIK<&M@JKEJMEJLOG&AD@HJ&J@&IAA@MEICE@J&HECD&<l=@A>?<&
C@&.*+&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFAR&;& <?<B@?<&B>?CD<?&?<A<I?MD&EJC@&
CDEA& IAA@MEICE@J& AD@>OF& T<& LEK<J& K<?G& O@H& =?E@?ECG& 4:
6R& +@?& IF>OC& O<>WI<PEI& IJF& T?IEJ& MIJM<?& CD<&?<M@P:
P<JFICE@J&EA&C@&>=FIC<&CD<&<lEACEJL&OI?L<&M@D@?CA&@B&@M:
M>=ICE@JIOOG&<l=@A<F&EJFEKEF>IOAR&!MM>=ICE@JIO&AC>FE<AS&
=@@O<F& IJIOGA<A& IJF& P<CI:IJIOGA<A& B@?& O<>WI<PEI& IJF&
T?IEJ& MIJM<?& DIK<& T<<J& EJM@JAEAC<JC& IJF& EJM@JMO>AEK<R&
g@H<K<?S&J<H&FICI&DIK<&A>TA<m><JCOG&T<<J&=>TOEAD<F&
IJF&AD@>OF&T<&>A<F&C@&>=FIC<&CD<A<&IJIOGA<A&4SS6R&
;& <&=?E@?ECG&EA&C@&IFF?<AA&CD<&<=EF<PE@O@LEMIO&<KEF<JM<&
TG&<ACITOEADEJL&I==?@=?EIC<&EJ&KEC?@&IJF&IJEPIO&P@F<OA&
B@?&?<A=@JA<A&C@&O@H:O<K<O&.*+&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFA&CDIC&I?<&
HEF<OG& C?IJAB<?ITO<& T<CH<<J& OIT@?IC@?E<AR& ]?IJAL<JEM&
?@F<JC& P@F<OA& B@?& MDEOFD@@F& O<>WI<PEI& AD@>OF& T<& F<:
K<O@=<F&EJ&@?F<?&C@&=?@KEF<&I==?@=?EIC<&<l=<?EP<JCIO&
IJEPIO&P@F<OA&C@&AC>FG&CD<&<N& <MC&@B&.*+&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OF&
<l=@A>?<& 4S& S6R&!CD<?HEA<S& B@?& <lEACEJL& IJEPIO&
AC>FE<AS&CD<&H<ELDC&@B&<KEF<JM<&EA&CDIC&CD<?<&I?<&J@&MI?ME:
J@L<JEM&<N& <MCA&@B&.*+&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFA&IO@J<R&;& <?<B@?<&
DELD&=?E@?ECG&AD@>OF&T<&LEK<J&C@&EJ&KEC?@&IJF&IJEPIO&AC>F:
E<A&EJ&HDEMD&.*+&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFA&I?<&?EL@?@>AOG&<KIO>IC<F&
IA&I&M@:MI?MEJ@L<JR&ZECD&?<LI?F&C@&@CD<?&EJ&KEC?@&AC>FE<AS&
<l=<?EP<JCA&?<=@?CEJL&CD<&L<J@C@lEM&<N& <MCA&@B&EJC<?PEC:
C<JC&.*+&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OF&<l=@A>?<&AD@>OF&T<&?<=OEMIC<F&
4S6R& ]D?<<& EJF<=<JF<JC& OI?L<:AMIO<& AC>FE<A& @B&?ICA&
=?@KEF<F&J@&<KEF<JM<&@B&IJ&<N& <MC&@B&.*+&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFA&
@J& CD<& EJMEF<JM<& @B& A=@JCIJ<@>A& PIPPI?G& C>P@>?A&
4:6R&-@AC&AC>FE<A&?<=@?C&J@&<N& <MC&@B&.*+&PILJ<CEM&
BE<OFA& @J& O<>WI<PEI& @?& OGP=D@PI& EJ&?@F<JC& P@F<OAR&
"<K<?IO& OI?L<:AMIO<& O@JL:C<?P& AC>FE<A& EJ&?@F<JCA& DIK<&
J@C&AD@HJ&IJG&M@JAEAC<JC&EJM?<IA<&EJ&IJG&CG=<&@B&MIJM<?S&
EJMO>FEJL&DI<PIC@=@E<CEMS&PIPPI?GS&T?IEJ&IJF&AWEJ&C>:
P@>?A&4:6R&%&A>TACIJCEIO&J>PT<?&@B&AC>FE<A&DIK<&<l:
IPEJ<F&CD<&<N& <MCA&@B&.*+&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFA&@J&MD<PEMIOOG:
EJF>M<F&PIPPI?G&C>P@>?A&EJ&?ICA&4S6R&$JM@JAEAC<JC&
?<A>OCA& H<?<& @TCIEJ<F& CDIC& PIG& T<& F><& EJ& HD@O<& @?& EJ&
=I?C&C@&FEN& <?<JM<A&EJ&<l=<?EP<JCIO&=?@C@M@OAS&A>MD&IA&CD<&
>A<&@B&A=<MEQ&M&A>T:AC?IEJAR&-@AC&AC>FE<A&@J&CD<&<N& <MCA&@B&
.*+&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OF&<l=@A>?<&@J&MD<PEMIOOG:EJF>M<F&@?&
?IFEICE@J:EJF>M<F&O<>WI<PEIOGP=D@PI&P@F<OA&H<?<&
J<LICEK<R&"C>FE<A&@B&=?<:J<@=OIACEM&OEK<?&O<AE@JAS&MD<PE:
MIOOG:EJF>M<F&AWEJ&C>P@>?A&IJF&T?IEJ&C>P@>?A&?<=@?C<F&
=?<F@PEJIJCOG&J<LICEK<&?<A>OCAR&!J<&AC>FG&?<=@?C<F&IJ&
IMM<O<?ICE@J&@B&(^:EJF>M<F&AWEJ&C>P@>?EL<J<AEA&>=@J&
<l=@A>?<&C@&.*+&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFA&46R&]H@&L?@>=A&DIK<&
?<=@?C<F&EJM?<IA<F&O<K<OA&@B&/#%&AC?IJF&T?<IWA&EJ&T?IEJ&
CEAA><&B@OO@HEJL&EJ&KEK@&<l=@A>?<&C@&.*+&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFAR&
g@H<K<?S& @CD<?& L?@>=AS& >AEJL& I& KI?E<CG& @B& FEN& <?<JC&?@:
F<JC& L<J@C@lEMECG& P@F<OAS& B@>JF& J@& <KEF<JM<& @B& L<J@:
C@lEM& <BB<MCAR& ]D<&?<A>OCA& @B& AC>FE<A& EJK<ACELICEJL& J@J:
L<J@C@lEM& <BB<MCA&?<O<KIJC& C@& MIJM<?& I?<& EJM@JMO>AEK<R&
!K<?IOO&CD<?<&EA&J@&<KEF<JM<&CDIC&<l=@A>?<&C@&.*+&PIL:
J<CEM&Q&<OFA&IO@J<&MI>A<A&C>P@>?AR&;& <&<KEF<JM<&CDIC&.*+&
PILJ<CEM&Q&<OF&<l=@A>?<&MIJ&<JDIJM<&C>P@>?&F<K<O@=:
P<JC& EJ& M@PTEJICE@J& HECD& MI?MEJ@L<JA& EA& EJIF<m>IC<R
]D<& =@H<?& IJF& P@TEO<& =D@J<& M@P=IJE<AS& D@=EJL& C@&
IK@EF& OECELICE@JS& @BC<J& IAA<?C& CDIC& T<MI>A<& CD<& <J<?LG&
@B&CD<&Q&<OFA&EA&C@@&O@H&C@&LEK<&AELJEQ&MIJC&D<ICEJLS&CD<G&
MIJJ@C&DIK<&IJG&TE@O@LEMIO&<N& <MC&4S6&R&g@H<K<?S&CD<&
<KEF<JM<& CDIC& <O<MC?@PILJ<CEM& BE<OFA& MIJ& DIK<& nJ@J:
CD<?PIOo&TE@O@LEMIO&<N& <MCA&EA&J@H&@K<?HD<OPEJL&4:6R&
$J& IFFECE@JS& EC& EA& IOA@&?<M@PP<JF<F& CDIC& CD<& <lEACEJL&
=@@O<F&IJIOGA<A&T<&>=FIC<FS&TG&IFFEJL&FICI&B?@P&?<M<JC&
AC>FE<A& IJF& TG& I==OGEJL& J<H& EJAELDCA& EJC@& CD<& IJIOGAEAR&
+@?&J<H&<=EF<PE@O@LEMIO&AC>FE<A&C@&T<&EJB@?PICEK<&CD<G&
P>AC&B@M>A&@J&J<H&IA=<MCA&@B&<l=@A>?<S&=@C<JCEIO&EJC<?:
IMCE@J&HECD&@CD<?&BIMC@?A&@?&@J&DELD&<l=@A>?<&L?@>=AS&@?&
@CD<?HEA<&T<&EJJ@KICEK<&EJ&CDEA&I?<I&@B&?<A<I?MD&4]ITO<&6R&
,IJM<?)<M@PP<JFICE@J
(=FIC<&<lEACEJL&=@@O<F&IJIOGA<A&@B&MDEOFD@@F&O<>WI<PEI&HECD&J<H&EJB@?PICE@J gELD
_@@O<F&IJIOGA<A&@B&<lEACEJL&AC>FE<A&@B&MDEOFD@@F&T?IEJ&C>P@>?&AC>FE<A gELD
(=FIC<&<lEACEJL&=@@O<F&IJF&P<CI:IJIOGA<A&@B&IF>OC&O<>WI<PEI&IJF&T?IEJ&C>P@>?&AC>FE<A&IJF&@B&M@D@?CA&@B&@MM>=ICE@JIOOG&
<l=@A<F&EJFEKEF>IOA
-<FE>P
/<K<O@=P<JC&@B&C?IJAL<JEM&?@F<JC&P@F<OA&@B&MDEOFD@@F&O<>WI<PEI&B@?&>A<&EJ&.*+&AC>FE<A gELD
.KIO>ICE@J&@B&M@:MI?MEJ@L<JEM&<N&<MCA&>AEJL&EJ&KEC?@&IJF&IJEPIO&AC>FE<A gELD
%CC<P=C<F&?<=OEMICE@J&@B&EJ&KEC?@&L<J@C@lEMECG&AC>FE<A -<FE>P
]% *.&5R&)<M@PP<JFICE@JA&B@?&B>?CD<?&?<A<I?MD&A@>?M<AS&P<IA>?<P<JCA&IJF&<l=@A>?<A
Conclusion
,@JA<m><JCOGS&EJ&CDEA&?<KE<HS&H<&PIG&IAA<?C&CDIC&CD<?<&I?<&AELJEQ&MIJC&<N& <MCA&@B&.-+&@J&CD<&MIJM<?&F<K<O@=P<JCR&$J&IF:
FECE@J&P@?<&M@P=?<D<JAEK<&B>C>?<&EJK<ACELICE@JA&I?<&?<m>E?<F&C@&F<C<?PEJ<&F<Q&JEC<&<N& <MCA&@B&.-+&@J&D>PIJ&FEA<IA<AR
 !"#$%#&'!()#%*&!+& %"$,&-./$,%*&",$.#,."&01213&21&4567&08y:091
^%g/.]]$#& %Y%h$]&.]&%*R7&.^%*(%]$!#&!+&,%),$#!i.#$,&.++.,]"&!+&.*.,])!-%i#.]$,&+$.*/"&.-+
References
46& +?<JMD& _RZRS& _<JJG& )RS& *I>?<JM<&'R%RS& -MX<J`E<&/R)R& -@TEO<&
=D@J<AS&D<IC&AD@MW&=?@C<EJA&IJF&MIJM<?R&/EN&<?<JCEICE@JR&3&7&
:R
46& $KIJMAECA&"RS&/E<P&.RS&'IDJ&!RS& )>FEL<?& gRZR& $JC<?PECC<JC& <l:
C?<P<OG&O@H&B?<m><JMG&<O<MC?@PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFA&MI>A<&/#%&FIP:
IL<&EJ&I&F@A<:F<=<JF<JC&HIGR&$JCR&%?MDR&!MM>=R&.JKE?@JR&g<IOCDR&
3&7:R
46& Z@OB& +R$RS& ]@?A<OO@& %RS& ]<F<AM@& RS& +IAIJ<OOI&"RS& @JEJA<LJI& %RS&
/|%AM<J`@& -RS& i?IAAE&,RS& %``<JI& iR RS&,ECCIFEJE& %R& :g`& <l:
C?<P<OG&O@H&B?<m><JMG&<O<MC?@PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFA&<JDIJM<&M<OO&=?@:
OEB<?ICE@J& IJF&/#%& FIPIL<7& =@AAETO<& EJK@OK<P<JC& @B& I&?<F@l&
P<MDIJEAPR& E@MDEPR& E@=DGAR&%MCIR&3&7:R
46& +<F?@HEC`&-RS&XIPEJ@&XRS&*{AMD<?&ZR&"ELJEQ&MIJC&FEN&<?<JM<A&EJ&
CD<&<N&<MCA&@B&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OF&<l=@A>?<&@J&S:FEP<CDGOT<J`4I6
IJCD?IM<J<:EJF>M<F&PIPPI?G&MI?MEJ@L<J<AEA&EJ&CH@&A>TAC?IEJA&
@B&"=?IL><:/IHO<G&?ICAR&,IJM<?&)<AR&3&7:R
46& iE?L<?C&)RS&"MDEPPEJL&gRS&X@?J<?&ZRS&i?>JFW<?&,R&IJF&gIJB&^R&
$JF>MCE@J&@B&CIP@lEB<J&?<AEACIJM<&EJ&T?<IAC&MIJM<?&M<OOA&TG&.*+&
<O<MC?@PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFAR& E@MD<PR& E@=DGAR&)<AR&,@PP>JR&3&
7:R
46& _IMEJE&"RS&)>LLE<?@&-RS&"I?FE&$RS&%C<?EJE&"RS&i>OEAIJ@&+RS&i>OEAIJ@&
-R&.l=@A>?<&C@&LO@TIO&AGAC<P&B@?&P@TEO<&M@PP>JEMICE@J&4i"-6&
M<OO>OI?& =D@J<&?IFE@B?<m><JMG& IOC<?A& L<J<& & <l=?<AAE@JS& =?@OEB:
<?ICE@JS&IJF&P@?=D@O@LG&@B&D>PIJ&AWEJ&Q&T?@TOIACAR&!JM@OR&)<AR&
3&7:R
46& )@CE&'R*R&-<IA>?<P<JC&@B&/#%&FIPIL<&IJF&I=@=C@AEA&EJ&-@OC:&
M<OOA&IBC<?&EJ&KEC?@&<l=@A>?<&C@&?IFE@B?<m><JMG&?IFEICE@JR&)IFEICR&
)<AR&3&7:R
46& $J@><& YRS&"IC@& YRS&#EADEP>?I& -RS&"<L>MDE& -RS& hIECA>& YRS& YI:
PIFI& XRS&!WI& YR& g<IC:EJF>M<F& F?>L&?<AEACIJM<& EA& IAA@MEIC<F&
HECD& EJM?<IA<F& <l=?<AAE@J& @B& MO:& EJ& g*R& %JCEMIJM<?& )<AR&
37:R
46& $ADEF@&-RS&#ECCI&gRS&XIT>C@&-R&-ILJ<CEM&Q&<OFA&4-+6&@B&&g`&IC&
R&PEM?@]&IA&H<OO&IA&&PEM?@]&MI>A<&>JM@>=OEJL&@B&EJDETEC@?G&
=ICDHIGA&@B&IF<JGOGO&MGMOIA<&P<FEIC<F&TG&P<OIC@JEJ&I&?<M<=C@?&
EJ& -+:A<JAECEK<& -,+:& M<OOAR&,I?MEJ@L<J<AEAR& 3& 7& :
R
46& -EGIW@ADE&'RS&]IW<PIAI&XRS&]IWIADEPI&YRS&/EJL&iR)RS&gE?@A<&gRS&
X@GIPI&"R&.N&<MCA&@B&<l=@A>?<&C@&I&&-g`&?IFE@&B?<m><JMG&
Q&<OF&@J&<l=?<AAE@J&@B&gA=&IJF&gA=&EJ&D>PIJ&LOE@PI&M<OOAR&
E@<O<MC?@PILJ<CEMAR&3&7:R
46&#EW@O@KI& ]RS&,`G`&'RS& )@OO<CAMD<W& %RS& OGA`M`>W& _RS& +>MDA&'RS&'@:
KCMD<K&iRS&"MD>F<?<?&'RS&X>AC<?&#RS&Z@T>A&%R-R&.O<MC?@PILJ<CEM&
Q&<OFA& IN&<MC& C?IJAM?E=C& O<K<OA& @B& I=@=C@AEA:?<OIC<F& L<J<A& EJ& <P:
T?G@JEM&AC<P&M<OOF<?EK<F&J<>?IO&=?@L<JEC@?&M<OOAR&+%". &'R&3&
7:R
46&"EPW€& -RS& gI?CHEL&,RS& *IJC@H& -RS& *>=W<& -RS& -ICCAA@J& -R!RS&
)IDPIJ&RS&)@OOHEC`&'R&gA=&&<l=?<AAE@J&IJF&B?<<&?IFEMIO&?<O<IA<&
IBC<?&<l=@A>?<&C@&J@J:CD<?PIO&?IFE@:B?<m><JMG&<O<MC?@PILJ<CEM&
Q&<OFA&IJF&>OC?IQ&J<&=I?CEMO<A&EJ&D>PIJ&-@J@&-IM&&M<OOAR&]@lEM@OR&
*<CCR&3&7:R
46& h@@W& R,RS&"EPP<JA&"R'R&;& <&<N&<MCA&@B&&-g`&?IFE@B?<m><JMG&
?IFEICE@J& @J& CD<& EJF>MCE@J& @?& =?@P@CE@J& @B& T?IEJ& C>P@?A& IJF&
@CD<?&J<@=OIAPA&EJ&?ICAR&)IFEICR&)<AR&3&7:R
46&'@DIJA<J&,RS& @EM<&'RS&'?RS& -M*I>LDOEJ&'RS&!OA<J&'R&,<OO>OI?& C<O<:
=D@J<A& IJF& MIJM<?:I& JICE@JHEF<& M@D@?C& AC>FG& EJ&/<JPI?WR&'R&
#ICOR&,IJM<?&$JACR&3&7:R
46& g<=H@?CD&"R'RS&"MD@<PIW<?&-R'RS&->E?&XR)RS&"H<?FO@H&%R'RS&^IJ&
]@JL<?<J&-R'RS&-MXEJJ<G&_R%R&-@TEO<&=D@J<&>A<&IJF&?EAW&@B&LOE@:
PI&EJ&IF>OCA7&MIA<:M@JC?@O&AC>FGR& -'R&3&467:R
46&"MD‚`&'RS& {DO<?&.RS& <?L&iRS&"MDO<D@B<?& RS&g<CCEJL<?&$RS&"MDOI<B<?&
XRS&ZID?<JF@?B&'RS&X>JJI:i?IAA&XRS& O<CCJ<?&-R&,<OO>OI?&=D@J<AS&
M@?FO<AA&=D@J<AS&IJF&CD<&?EAW&@B&LOE@PI&IJF&P<JEJLE@PIR&%PR&'R&
.=EF<PE@OR&3&7:R
46& gI?F<OO&*RS&,I?OT<?L&-RS&gIJAA@J&-EOF&XRR&,IA<:M@JC?@O&AC>FG&@J&
M<OO>OI?&IJF&M@?FO<AA&C<O<=D@J<A&IJF&CD<&?EAW&B@?&IM@>ACEM&J<>?@:
PI&@?&P<JEJLE@PI&EJ&=ICE<JCA&FEILJ@A<F&:R&#<>?@<=E:
F<PE@O@LGR&3&&7:R
46& gI?F<OO&*RS&,I?OT<?L&-RS&-EOF&XRgR&,IA<:M@JC?@O&AC>FG&@B&CD<&IA:
A@MEICE@J&T<CH<<J&CD<&>A<&@B&M<OO>OI?&IJF&M@?FO<AA&C<O<=D@J<A&IJF&
PIOELJIJC& T?IEJ& C>P@?A& FEILJ@A<F& F>?EJL& :R&.JKE?@JR&
)<AR&3&7:R
46&,D?EAC<JA<J&gR,RS&"MD‚`&'RS&X@AC<OzIJ<C`&-RS&_@>OA<J&gR"RS& @EM<&
'R/RS&'?RS&-M*I>LDOEJ&'RXRS&'@DIJA<J&,R&,<OO>OI?&C<O<=D@J<A&IJF&?EAW&
B@?&T?IEJ&C>P@?A7&I&=@=>OICE@J:TIA<FS&EJMEF<JC&MIA<:M@JC?@O&AC>FGR&
#<>?@O@LGR&3&7:R
46& *{AMD<?&ZRS&-<KEAA<J&-RS&*<DPIMD<?&ZRS&"CIPP&%R&]>P@?&=?@:
P@CE@J&EJ&I&T?<IAC&MIJM<?&P@F<O&TG&<l=@A>?<&C@&I&H<IW&IOC<?JIC:
EJL&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFR&,IJM<?&*<CCR&3&7:R
46&"MD@<PIW<?&-R'RS&"H<?FO@H&%R'RS&%DOT@P&%RS&%>KEJ<J&%RS& OIIA:
IIA&XRiRS&,I?FEA&.RS&,D?EAC<JA<J&gR,RS&+<GMDCEJL&-RS&g<=H@?CD&
"R'RS&'@DIJA<J&,RS&XOI<T@<&*RS&*@JJ&"RS&-MXEJJ<G&_R%RS&->E?&XRS&
)IECIJ<J&'RS&"IOPEJ<J&]RS&;& @PA<J&'RS&]GJ<A&]R&-@TEO<&=D@J<&>A<&
IJF&?EAW&@B&IM@>ACEM&J<>?@PI7&?<A>OCA&@B&CD<&$JC<?=D@J<&MIA<:M@J:
C?@O&AC>FG&EJ&Q&K<&#@?CD&.>?@=<IJ&M@>JC?E<AR& ?R&'R&,IJM<?R&3&
7:R
46& %DOT@P&%RS&/IG&#RS&+<GMDCEJL&-RS&)@PIJ&.RS&"WEJJ<?&'RS&/@MW<?CG&
'RS&*EJ<C&-RS&-M ?EF<&-RS&-EMDI<OEA&'RS&!OA<J&'RgR&IJF&@CD<?AR&%&
=@@O<F&IJIOGAEA&@B&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OFA&IJF&MDEOFD@@F&O<>WI<PEIR& ?R&'R&
,IJM<?R&3&7:R
46& +@OEI?C&/R.RS&_@OO@MW& RgRS&-<`<E&iRS&$?EG<&)RS&"EOKI&'R-RS&.TE&XR*RS&
XD<EB<CA&*RS&*EJW&-R_RS&XIK<C&)R&-ILJ<CEM&Q&<OF&<l=@A>?<&IJF&O@JL:
C<?P&A>?KEKIO&IP@JL&MDEOF?<J&HECD&O<>WI<PEIR& ?R&'R&,IJM<?R&3&
7:R
46& %JIJ<&)RS&/>O@>&_R.RS&]IlEO<&-RS&i<N&I?F&-RS&,?<A=<I>&+R*RS&^<G:
?<C& R&.N&<MCA&@B&i"-:&PEM?@HIK<A&@J&/- %:EJF>M<F&PIP:
PI?G&LOIJF&C>P@?A&EJ&B<PIO<&"=?IL><:/IHO<G&?ICAR&)IFEICR&)<AR&
3&7:R
46& %JF<?A@J& *.S& @@?PIJ& i%S& -@??EA&'.S&"IAA<?& * S& -IJJ& _,S&
i?>PT<EJ&"*S&gIEO<G&')S&-M#IOOG&%S&"EOOA&),S&gIA<PIJ&'XR&.N&<MC&
@B&&H<<W&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OF&<l=@A>?<A&@J&/- %:EJECEIC<F&PIP:
PI?G&LOIJF&MI?MEJ@PIA&EJ&B<PIO<&"=?IL><:/IHO<G&?ICAR&,I?MEJ@:
L<J<AEAR&3&7:R
46& OIMWPIJ&,R+RS& <JIJ<&"RiR&IJF&g@>A<&/R.R&;& <&EJƒ&><JM<&@B&R&
PEM?@]S& & g`& PILJ<CEM& Q&<OFA& @J& P<OIC@JEJ:& IJF& CIP@lEB<J:
EJF>M<F&EJDETECE@J&@B&-,+:&M<OO&L?@HCDR& E@<O<MC?@PILJ<CEMAR&
3&7:R
List of Abbreviations
.-+&:&.O<MC?@PILJ<CEM&+E<OF
.*+&:&.lC?<P<OG&*@H&+?<m><JME<A
$%),&:& $JC<?JICE@JIO&%L<JMG&B@?&)<A<I?MD&@J&,IJM<? 
 !"#$%#&'!()#%*&!+& %"$,&-./$,%*&",$.#,."&01213&21&4567&091:091
^%g/.]]$#& %Y%h$]&.]&%*R7&.^%*(%]$!#&!+&,%),$#!i.#$,&.++.,]"&!+&.*.,])!-%i#.]$,&+$.*/"&.-+
46& +@?AA<J&(R-RS&)>CmKEAC&*R.RS&%DOT@P&%RS&+<GMDCEJL&-R&!MM>=I:
CE@JIO& PILJ<CEM& Q&<OFA& IJF& B<PIO<& T?<IAC& MIJM<?7& I&MIA<:M@JC?@O&
AC>FG&>AEJL&"H<FEAD&=@=>OICE@J&?<LEAC<?A&IJF&J<H&<l=@A>?<&FICIR&
%PR&'R&.=EF<PE@OR&3&7:R
46& %>KEJ<J&%RS&gE<CIJ<J&-RS&*>>WW@J<J&)RS&X@AW<OI&)R"R& ?IEJ&C>:
P@?A&IJF&AIOEKI?G&LOIJF&MIJM<?A&IP@JL&M<OO>OI?&C<O<=D@J<&>A<?AR&
.=EF<PE@O@LGR&3&7:R
46& <?L&iRS&"MD‚`&'RS&"IPWIJL<:h<<T&+RS& O<CCJ<?&-R&%AA<AAP<JC&@B&
?IFE@B?<m><JMG&<l=@A>?<&B?@P&M<OO>OI?&C<O<=D@J<&FIEOG&>A<&EJ&IJ&
<=EF<PE@O@LEMIO& AC>FGR&'R&.l=@& %JIOR&.JKE?@J&.=EF<PE@OR& 3&
7:R
46& )@OOHEC`&'RS& *>=W<& -RS&"EPW€& -R& +EBCG:D<?C`& PILJ<CEM& Q&<OFA& EJ:
F>M<& B?<<&?IFEMIO& B@?PICE@J& EJ& P@>A<& T@J<& PI??@H:F<?EK<F&
=?@P@J@MGC<A&IJF&PIM?@=DIL<AR& E@MDEPR& E@=DGAR&%MCIR&7&
7:R
46& -<KEAA<J& -RS& *<?MDO& %RS&"`IP<O& -RS& *{AMD<?& ZR&.l=@A>?<& @B&
/- %:C?<IC<F&B<PIO<&?ICA&EJ&I&:g`S&&PEM?@]<AOI&PILJ<CEM&
Q&<OF7&<N&<MCA&@J&PIPPI?G&C>P@?&L?@HCDS&P<OIC@JEJ&O<K<OAS&IJF&]&
OGP=D@MGC<&IMCEKICE@JR&,I?MEJ@L<J<AEAR&3&7:R
46& +<F?@HEC`&-RS&Z<AC<?PIJJ&'RS&*{AMD<?&ZR&-ILJ<CEM&Q&<OF&<l=@:
A>?<&EJM?<IA<A&M<OO&=?@OEB<?ICE@J&T>C&F@<A&J@C&IN&<MC&P<OIC@JEJ&O<K:
<OA&EJ&CD<&PIPPI?G&LOIJF&@B&B<PIO<&"=?IL><&/IHO<G&?ICAR&,IJM<?&
)<AR&3&7:R
46& @@?PIJ&iR%RS&%JF<?A@J&*R.RS&-@??EA&'R.RS&"IAA<?&*R RS&-IJJ&_R,RS&
i?>PT<EJ&"R*RS&gIEO<G&'R)RS&-M#IOOG&%RS&"EOOA&)R,RS&gIA<PIJ&'RXR&
.N&<MC&@B&&H<<W&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OF&<l=@A>?<A&EJ&I&/- %&EJECEICE@J:
=?@P@CE@J&PIPPI?G&LOIJF&P@F<O&EJ&"=?IL><:/IHO<G&?ICAR&,I?:
MEJ@L<J<AEAR&3&7:R
46& *{AMD<?&ZR&/@&M@MI?MEJ@L<JEM&<N&<MCA&@B&.*+&<O<MC?@PILJ<CEM&
Q&<OFA&?<m>E?<&?<=<IC<F&O@JL:C<?P&EJC<?IMCE@J&HECD&MI?MEJ@L<JA…&
,DI?IMC<?EACEMA&@B&=@AECEK<&AC>FE<A&>AEJL&CD<&/- %&T?<IAC&MIJM<?&
P@F<O&EJ&?ICAR& E@<O<MC?@PILJ<CEMAR&3&7:R
46&/E<P&.RS&"MDHI?`&,RS&%OFW@B<?&+RS&'IDJ&!RS&)>FEL<?&gR&#@J:CD<?:
PIO&/#%&T?<IWIL<&TG&P@TEO<&=D@J<&?IFEICE@J&4&-g`6&EJ&
D>PIJ&Q&T?@TOIACA&IJF&EJ&C?IJAB@?P<F&i+"g:)&?IC&L?IJ>O@AI&
M<OOA&EJ&KEC?@R&->CICE@J&)<A<I?MDR&3&7:R
46& X>POEJ& ]RS& X@API& ^R-RS& %OD@J<J& *RS&'IJJ<&'RS& X@P>OIEJ<J& gRS&
*IJL&"RS&)GC@PII&]RS&"<?K@PII&XRS&'>>CEOIEJ<J&'R&.N&<MCA&@B&&g`&
PILJ<CEM& BE<OFA& @J& (^:EJF>M<F& AWEJ& C>P@?EL<J<AEA& EJ&!/,:
C?IJAL<JEM& IJF& J@JC?IJAL<JEM& PEM<R& $JCR&'R& )IFEICR& E@OR& 3&
7:R
46& $PIEFI&XRS&X>`>CIJE&XRS&ZIJL&'RS&+>zEHI?I&!RS&!LEA@&]RS&XIC@&XRS&
"DE?IE&]R&*IMW&@B&=?@P@CE@J&@B&S:&FEP<CDGOT<J`†I‡IJCD?IM<J<:
EJECEIC<F&P@>A<&AWEJ&MI?MEJ@L<J<AEA&TG&R&ig`&<O<MC?@PILJ<CEM&
J<I?&Q&<OFAR&,I?MEJ@L<J<AEAR&3&7:R
46& %JIJ<& )RS& i<N& I?F& -RS& ]IlEO<& -RS& @F<C&/RS& EOOI>F<O& RS&/>O@>&
_R.RS&IJF&^<G?<C& R&.N&<MCA&@B&i"-:&PEM?@HIK<A&@J&CD<&<l=<?:
EP<JCIO&IOO<?LEM&<JM<=DIO@PG<OECEA&4.%.6&?IC&P@F<O&@B&P>OCE=O<&
AMO<?@AEAR& E@<O<MC?@PILJ<CEMAR&3&7:R
46& I>P&%RS&-<KEAA<J&-RS&XIPEJ@&XRS&-@D?&(RS&*@AMD<?&ZR&%&DEA:
C@=ICD@O@LEMIO&AC>FG&@J&IOC<?ICE@JA&EJ&/- %:EJF>M<F&PIPPI?G&
MI?MEJ@L<J<AEA&EJ&?ICA&HECD&&g`S&&P>]&PILJ<CEM&Q&<OF&<l=@:
A>?<R&,I?MEJ@L<J<AEAR3&7:R
46& <AA<C&%RS&.A=I&+RS&/I>KEOOE<?A&YRS& EOOEI?F&-RS&F<&"<`<&)R&#@&<N&<MC&
@J&M@LJECEK<&B>JMCE@J&B?@P&FIEOG&P@TEO<&=D@J<&>A<R& E@<O<MC?@:
PILJ<CEMAR&3&7:R
46& ){AMDW<&'RS&-IJJ&XR&#@&AD@?C:C<?P&<N&<MCA&@B&FELECIO&P@TEO<&?IFE@&
C<O<=D@J<&@J&CD<&IHIW<&D>PIJ&<O<MC?@<JM<=DIO@L?IPR& E@<O<M:
C?@PILJ<CEMAR&3&7:R
46& XD<EB<CA&*RS&)<=IMD@OE&-RS&"I>JF<?A&)RS&KIJ&/<K<JC<?&.R&;& <&A<J:
AECEKECG& @B& MDEOF?<J& C@& <O<MC?@PILJ<CEM& BE<OFAR& _<FEIC?EMAR& 3&
7:R
46& X@EKEAC@&-RS&)<K@JA>@&%RS&X?I>A<&,RS&gII?IOI&,RS&"EOOIJPIWE&*RS&
*IEJ<& -RS& gIPIOIEJ<J& gR&.N& <MCA& @B& & -g`& <O<MC?@PILJ<CEM&
Q&<OF&<PECC<F&TG&M<OO>OI?&C<O<=D@J<A&@J&?<A=@JA<&CEP<A&EJ&D>PIJAR&
#<>?@?<=@?CR&3&7:R
46&,D?EAC<JA<J&gR,RS&"MD‚`&'RS&X@AC<OzIJ<C`&-RS&_@>OA<J&gR"RS&;& @P:
A<J&'S&'@DIJA<J&,R&,<OO>OI?&C<O<=D@J<&>A<&IJF&?EAW&@B&IM@>ACEM&J<>:
?@PIR&%PR&'R&.=EF<PE@OR&3&7:R
46& $JAWE=&_R/RS&]I?@J<&)R.RS&gICMD&.R.RS&ZEOM@AWG&]R,RS&"DI=E?@&ZR)RS&
"<OW<?&)RiRS&+EJ<&gR%RS& OIMW&_R-RS&*@<ˆ&&<?&'R"RS&*EJ<C&-R"R&,<OO>:
OI?:C<O<=D@J<&>A<&IJF&T?IEJ&C>P@?AR&#R&.JLOR&'R&-<FR&3&7:
R
46& *{JJ&"RS& %DOT@P& %RS& gIOO& _RS& +<GMDCEJL& -R& *@JL:C<?P& P@TEO<&
=D@J<&>A<&IJF&T?IEJ&C>P@?&?EAWR&%PR&'R&.=EF<PE@OR&3&7:
R
46& gI?F<OO&*RS&gIOOm>EAC&%RS&-EOF&XRgRS&,I?OT<?L&-RS&_IDOA@J&%RS&*EOzI&
%R&,<OO>OI?&IJF&M@?FO<AA&C<O<=D@J<A&IJF&CD<&?EAW&B@?&T?IEJ&C>P@?AR&
.>?R&'R&,IJM<?&_?<KR&3&7:R