CASE NO.2010D-001 COMPLAINANT: JOSEPH J LIPTOW 4501 ANDERSON ROAD SOUTH EUCLID, OHIO 44121

moanafternoonInternet και Εφαρμογές Web

11 Δεκ 2013 (πριν από 3 χρόνια και 8 μήνες)

174 εμφανίσεις

OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET






CASE NO.2010D
-
001




COMPLAINANT:

JOSEPH J LIPTOW








4501 ANDERSON ROAD




SOUTH EUCLID, OHIO 44121




216 538
-
0470


RESPONDENT:

DAVID B. MILLER



COUNSEL
:
EDWARD ICOVE




CITY OF SOUTH EUCLID



1751 S BELVOIR BLVD




COUNCIL
-
AT
-
LARGE



S EUCLID, OH 44121




3826 MERRYMOUND ROAD




SOUTH EUCLID, OH 44121


ALLEGATIONS:

3517.20(A)(2) (NO DISCLAIMER)


OFFICE:


SOUTH EUCLID CITY
COUNCIL
-
AT
-
LARGE


ELECTION:


NOVEMBER 3, 2009


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/1/2010
THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION




OF R. C. §3517.20(A)(2).



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET






CASE NO.2010E
-
002




COMPLAINANT:

OHIO HOUSE DEMOCRATIC
CAUCUS



COUNSEL:






340 E. FULTON ST.




MEGAN C. KELLEY




COLUMBUS, OHIO 43215



HAYMAN & KELLEY LLC.




216 538
-
0470





3010 HAYDEN RD










COLUMBUS, OH 43235







RESPONDENT:

OHIOANS FOR CLEAN GOVERNMENT




JAMES DULLEN, TREASURER




189 SPELL
MAN COURT




AKRON, OH 44305




(330) 535
-
2769



ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.21(B)(9) (FALSE STATEMENTS)

§3517.21(B)(10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)


OFFICE:




ELECTION:


NOVEMBER 3, 2009


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

6/17/2010 THE MATTER WAS WITHDRAWN BY THE COMPLAINANT.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET






CASE NO.

2010G
-
003




COMPLAINANT:

SPENCER PHELPS




671 MEADOW ST.




MARION, OHIO 43302




740 244
-
3658


RESPONDENT:

DAVE EDWARDS




1072 BAHAMA DRIVE




MARION, OH 43302




740 360
-
1442


ALLEGATIONS:

§35
17.10(A)(2) (FAILURE TO FILE A 2009 CAMPAIGN FINANCE




REPORT)


OFFICE:


MARION CITY COUNCIL PRESIDENT


ELECTION:


NOVEMBER
3,
2009


PRIORS:


2009D
-
051


DISPOSITION:

8/19/2010 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION OF R.C.
§3517.10(A)(2)




OHIO ELECTIONS
COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET






CASE NO. 2010D
-
004




COMPLAINANT:

EDWARD A. ICOVE




1751 SOUTH BELVOIR BLVD.




SOUTH EUCLID, OH 44121






RESPONDENT:

JOSEPH LIPTOW




4501 ANDERSON ROAD




SOUTH EUCLID, OHIO 44121




216 538
-
0470


ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.20 (INCOMPLETE DISCLAIMER)


OFFICE:


SOUTH EUCLID COUNCIL AT LARGE


ELECTION:


NOVEMBER 3, 2009


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

04/1/10 T
HE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF


R.C. §3517.20(A)(2) BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN NOT TO
IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATT
ER FOR FURTHER
PROSECUTION.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET






CASE NO. 2010E
-
005




COMPLAINANT:

JACKSON L. MCDANIEL




1605 FISHBACK RD




FAYETTE COUNTY, OH 45135
-
9510




740 335
-
4237





RESPONDENT:

WASHINGTON BLAZE




P O BOX 233




WASHINGTON C H, OH 43160




740 606
-
0366



FAX:

888
-
838
-
3158


ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.20(A)(1)(a) (INCOMPLETE DISCLAIMER)




§3517.21(B)(9) AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENT)


OFFICE:


FAYETTE COUNTY COMMISSIONER


ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

3/18/2010 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO PROBABLE CAUSE

AND DISMISSED THE MATTER.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET






CASE NO. 2010E
-
006




COMPLAINANT:

JEANETTE MOLL




803B MARKET ST




ZANESVILLE, OH 43701




740 297
-
4700



FAX:

740 297
-
778
2


RESPONDENT:

JENNIFER BRUNNER




180 E BROAD ST




COLUMBUS, OH 43215








ZACK SPACE




137 EAST IRON AVE




DOVER, OH 44622


ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.2
1(B)(8) AND (10)

(
FALSE STATEMENT
)



OFFICE:


UNITED STATES SENATE (OHIO)




U S REPRESENTATIVE


18
TH

DISTRICT


ELECTION:


MAY 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

3/18/2010 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO PROBABLE CAUSE

AND DISMISSED THE MATTER.





OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010
D
-
007




COMPLAINANT:

STEPHEN LANNY SPAULDING

COUNSEL
:

DONALD BREY




984 SEVERN DRIVE





65 E STATE ST




COSHOCTON, OH

43812




SUITE 1000




740 590
-
3698






COLS., OH 43215











614 221
-
4000










FAX:

614 221
-
4012


RESPONDENT:

MICHELLE SCHNEIDER


COUNSEL
: DAVID LANGDON




MICHELLE SCHNEIDER FO
R SENATE


LANGDON LAW LLC




ROBERT SCHNEIDER, TREASURER


11175 READING RD




9850 PIPEWELL LANE




SUITE 104




CINCINNATI, OH 45243
-
1129



CINCINNATI, OH 45241











513 733
-
1058










FAX

513 577
-
7383










CELL

513 604
-
5872



ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.
20(A)(13)

(INCOMPLETE DISCLAIMER)


OFFICE:


OHIO SENATE


7
TH

DISTRICT


ELECTION:


MAY
4,
2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

6/17/2010 THE MATTER WAS WITHDRAWN BY THE COMPLAINANT.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CA
SE NO. 2010E
-
008




COMPLAINANT:

EUGENE A. LUCCI




11535 MONARCH COURT




CONCORD
TWP., OH 44077




440 352
-
8505






440 336
-
1077





FRIENDS OF JUDGE EUGENE A LUCCI




WALTER J. MCNAMARA III, TREASURER




8440 STATION ST




MENTOR OH 44060




RESPONDENT:

COLLEEN MARY
O’TOOLE




6185 GRANDRIDGE POINTE DRIVE




CONCORD TWP., OH 44077





FRIENDS TO ELECT COLLEEN O’TOOLE




DIANE GOSS, TREASURER




34109 BEACHPARK AVE.




EASTLAKE, OH 44095





CURTIS LAU




8705 CLIFFWOOD COURT




MENTOR, OH 44060



ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.21
(A) (FALSE STATEMENTS)




§3517.20(A)(2
) (INCOMPLETE DISCLAIMER)


OFFICE:


JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS 11
TH

DIST


ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/1/2010 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE
WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION

AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.


OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
009




COMPLAINANT:

CURTIS LAU




8705 CLIFFWOOD COURT




MENTOR, OH 44060




440 487
-
1758


RESPONDENT:

FRIENDS OF JUDGE EUGENE LUCCI




WALTER J. MCNAMARA, III,

TREASURER

8440 STATION STREET





MENTOR, OH 44060

(W)

440 336
-
1077

(FAX)

440 255
-
9100




ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.21(B
)
(2)
,
(9) AND (10)

(FALSE STATEMENTS)





OFFICE:


JUDGE OF THE COURT OF APPEALS 11
TH

DIST


ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/1/2010 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE
WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.





OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010G
-
010




COMPLAINANT:

RYAN LYNCH




2972 OAKLAND AVE.




KETTERING,
OH 45409




937
-
293
-
0151


RESPONDENT:

CITIZENS FOR KETTERING CITY SCHOOLS PAC

COUNSEL
:

3750 FAR HILLS AVE.




MARIA ARMSTRONG




KETTERING, OH 45429




BRICKER & ECKLER











100 SOUTH THIRD ST.












COLUMBUS, OH 43215






KETTERING CITY
SCHOOLS BOARD OF EDUCATION

COUNSEL
:

3780 FAR HILLS AVE.




MARIA ARMSTRONG




KETTERING, OH 45429




(P) 937
-
499
-
1430




ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.08 (MATTERS NOT CONSIDERED CONTRIBUTION OR




EXPENDITURE)

§3517.092 (SOLICITATIONS FROM PUBLIC EMPLOYEES)





OFFICE:


LEVY


ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

5/13/2010 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.08




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
011




COMPLAINANT:

MATTHEW PARKER




243 NORTH FIFTH ST.




SUITE 330




COLUMBUS, OH 43215




614 384
-
5222


RESPONDENT:

KRIS JORDAN




161 STONEBEND DRIVE




POWELL, OHIO 43065




614 203
-
5365








PARKER NOVAK




161 STONEBEND DRIVE




POWELL, OHIO 43065




513 410
-
1144





RANDY TURNER




161 STONEBEND DRIVE




POWELL, OHIO 43065







ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)(4),(5) AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)





OFFICE:


OHIO STATE SENATE 19
TH

DISTRICT


ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/8/2010 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE

WAS NO PROBABLE
CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
012




COMPLAINANT:

STEPHEN LANNY SPAULDING

COUNSEL
: DONALD C. BREY




984 SEVERN DRIVE




65 E STATE ST #1000




COSHOCTON, OH 43812



CO
LS., OH 43215




740 590
-
3698


RESPONDENT:

MICHELLE SCHNEIDER


COUNSEL
:

DAVID LANGDON




MICHELLE SCHNEIDER FOR STATE SENATE

LANGDON LAW LLC




ROBERT SCHNEIDER, TREASURER


11175 READING RD #104




8750 PIPEWELL LANE




CINTI., OH 45241




CINCINNATI, OH
45243
-
1129




513 271
-
0908




ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)(8) AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENT)





OFFICE:


STATE SENTATE 7
TH

DISTRICT


ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

6/17/2010 THE MATTER WAS WITHDRAWN BY THE COMPLAINANT.


OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
01
3




COMPLAINANT:

SCOTT A PULLINS




110 EAST GAMBIER ST., 2
ND

FLOOR




MT VERNON, OH 43050
-
1186




740 392
-
3505



FAX:

202 330
-
4954




scott@pullinslaw.com



RESPONDENT:

THOM COLLIER


COUNSEL
: KELLY HAMILTON




607 E HIGH ST




MT VERNON, OH 43050




ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)
(10) (FALSE STATEMENT)





OFFICE:


STATE SEN
ATE 19
TH

DISTRICT


ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/8/2010 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE

WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF
A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.







OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET






CASE NO.2010E
-
014




COMPLAINANT:

JOHN JANSZEN


COUNSEL
:

CHRIS FINNEY




3850 FOXTAIL LA
NE



SABA & PATTERSON CO LPA




CINCINNATI, OH 45248



2623 ERIE AVE.










CINCINNATI, OH 452
08

















RESPONDENT:

CITIZENS FOR THREE RIVERS



COUNSEL
:

GARYT. STEDRONSKY




MIKE HINES






ENNIS, ROBERTS & FISHER

3929 DURANGO GREEN




1714 W. GALBRAITH RD.




CLEVES, OH 45002





CINCINNATI, OH 45239
-
4812











513
-
421
-
2540










FAX:

513
-
562
-
4986









DIRECT DIAL:

513
-
674
-
3447



ALLEGATIONS:

3517.22(B)(2) (FALSE STATEMENT)


ISSUE:


ISSUE 9


ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/15/2010

THE COMMISSION DISMISSED THE MATTER FOR FAILUR
E

TO CARRY THE STATUTORY BURDEN OF PROOF OF CLEAR AND
CONVINCING EVIDENCE.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET






CASE NO.2010E
-
015




COMPLAINANT:

BREYER FOR JUDGE COMMITTEE
COUNSEL
: JOSEPH BRAUN




237 MAIN ST






STRAUSS & TROY




BATAVIA OH 45103




FEDERAL RESERVE BLDG










150 EAST FOURTH ST










CINCINNATI, OH 45202
-
4018




DANIEL J BREYER




4998 MALLETT HILL DR




CINCINNATI, OH 45244


RESPONDENT:

COMMITTEE TO ELECT THOMAS R HERMAN JUDGE




THOMAS R HERMAN




4533 DAM
ERON LANE




CINCINNATI, OH 45244



ALLEGATIONS:

3517.2
0
(
A)(2) (INCOMPLETE DISCLAIMER)




3517.21 (B)(1) AND (10)(FALSE STATEMENT)



OFFICE:


CLERMON
T

COUNTY COMMON PLEAS CT JUDGE


ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/8/2010 THE PROBABLE
CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE

WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.





OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
016




COMPLAINANT:

SCOTT A PULLINS




110 EAST GAMBIER ST., 2
ND

FLOOR




MT VERNON, OH
43050
-
1186




740 392
-
3505



FAX:

202 330
-
4954




scott@pullinslaw.com



RESPONDENT:

THOM COLLIER


COUNSEL
: KELLY HAMILTON




607 E HIGH ST




MT VERNON, OH 43050




ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(10) (FALSE STATEMENT)





OFFICE:


STATE SENATE 19
TH

DISTRICT


ELECT
ION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/8/2010 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE

WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.





OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
017




COMPLAINANT:

GARY BROSKA




2212 AUGUSTA COURT




WESTLAKE, OH 44145



RESPONDENT:

FRIENDS OF JUDGE EUGENE LUCCI




WALTER J. MCNAMARA III, TREASURER




8440 STATION ST.




MENTOR, OH 44060




ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)(10)(FALSE STATEMENT)




OFFICE:




ELECTION:


MAY 4,

2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/15/2010 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE
WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.





OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
018




COMPLAINANT:

THEA SHOEMAKE



COUNSEL
: CHRIS FINNEY




4992 MALLET HILL DRIVE



SABA & PATTERSON CO LPA




CINCINNATI, OH 45244




2623 ERIE AVE










CINCINNATI, OH 45208










513 533
-
2980










(FAX) 513 533
-
2990







RESPONDENT:

OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY

COUNSEL
: MARIA
ARMSTRONG




211 S FIFTH ST




BRICKER & ECKLER




COLUMBUS, OH 43215



100 SOUTH THIRD ST.










COLUMBUS, OH 43215
-
4291






KEVIN DEWINE




CHAIRMAN, OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY




211 S FIFTH ST




COLUMBUS, OH 43215



ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)
(3),(8) AND

(10)(FALSE STATEMENT)




OFFICE:


REPUBLICAN STATE CENRAL COMMITTEE



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:

9/2/2010 THE COMMISSION ACCEPTED THE MOTION FOR SUMMARY
JUDGEMENT AND DISMISSED THE CASE.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO.
2010E
-
019




COMPLAINANT:

JAMES K TEDRICK




309 ROSE LANE ST SW




NORTH CANTON, OH 44720
-
3555



RESPONDENT:

THE VOTE FOR NORTH CANTON EMS COMMITTEE




KATHERINE BORESH, TREASURER




442 BROWNING AVE NW




NORTH CANTON, OH 44720



ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21

AND 3517.22(
FALSE STATEMENT)




ISSUE
:


ISSUE 10



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/26/2010
THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE
WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE

SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
020




COMPLAINANT:

DAVID T. DANIELS


COUNSEL:

WILLIAM TODD




440 NORTH ST.




41 S. HIGH ST. 26
TH

FLOOR




GREENFIELD, OH 45123



COLUMBUS, OH 43215



RESPONDENT:

CLYDE EVANS



COUNSEL:

DONALD C. BREY




177 LANE DR.




65 E. STATE ST. STE. 1000




RIO GRANDE, OH 45674



COLUMBUS, OH 43
215



ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21
(B)(9)

(FALSE STATEMENT)




ISSUE:


OHIO SENATE 17
TH

DISTRICT



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

8/19/2010 THE COMMISSION ACCEPTED THE JOINT REQU
EST TO
DISMISS THE COMPLAINT.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010G
-
021




COMPLAINANT:

CHRIS VERICH ELECTION CMTE
COUNSEL
:

DONALD MCTIGUE




1414 CENTRAL PARKWAY SE



550 E. WALNUT ST.




WARREN, OH 44484




COLUMBUS, OH
43215



RESPONDENT:

SELF REFERRAL





ALLEGATIONS:

3517.
13(D) (LATE AND INCOMPLETE FILING OF THE 2009 ANNUAL
REPORT)




ISSUE:


STATE REPRESENTATIVE



ELECTION:




PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

5/13/2010 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(D)
AND
IMPOSED A FINE OF $50. THE COMMISSION THEN DECLARED THE
COMMITTEE IN FULL COMPLIANCE AND IS NOW ABLE TO TERMINATE.



7/09/2010 RECEIVED MONEY ORDER #14
-
126197038 IN THE AMOUNT OF
$50 FROM CHRIS VERICH FOR PAYMENT OF THE FINE IMPOSED.



CASE CLOSED




OHIO

ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
022




COMPLAINANT:

EUGENE PIERCE


COUNSEL:

DONALD C. BREY




208 E. STATE ST.



65 E. STATE ST. STE. 1000




COLUMBUS, OH 43215


COLUMBUS, OH 43215




(P) 614
-
365
-
9494



RESPONDENT:

DAVID
DANIELS




FRIENDS OF DAVID DANIELS




KAREN S. DANIELS, TREASURER







440 NORTH ST.





GREENFIELD, OH 45123




(P) 614
-
981
-
3016






ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)(9) AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)




ISSUE:


OHIO SENATE 17
TH

DISTRICT



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

8/19/2010 THE COMMISSION ACCEPTED THE JOINT REQUEST TO
DISMISS THE COMPLAINT.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
023




COMPLAINANT:

JENNIFER ANNE ELICSON






4550 BIMINI DR.




GAHANNA, OH 43230




RESPONDENT:

OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY

COUNSEL:

MARIA ARMSTRONG




211 S. FIFTH ST.





BRICKER & ECKLER




COLUMBUS, OH 43215




100 SOUTH THIRD ST.












COLS, OH 43215
-
4291











614
-
227
-
2300











614
-
227
-
2390





OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY




KEVIN DEWINE, CHAIRMAN




211 S. FIFTH ST.




COLUMBUS, OH 43215






ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)(3)(8) AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)




ISSUE:


REPUBLICAN STATE CENRAL COMMITTEE



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/26/2010
THE PROBABLE CAUSE PA
NEL DETERMINED THAT THERE
WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
024




COMPLAINANT:

MIKE WILSON






2159 DEER MEADOW DR.




CINCINNATI, OH 45240









BRENDA L. BROWN




11812 PERCIVALE COURT




SHARONVILLE, OH





MILDRED DANIELS




4162 CRYSTALVIEW




SHARONVILLE, OH



RESPONDENT:

TOM WEIDMAN




CITIZENS FOR TOM WEIDMAN




8180 KEMPER RIDGE COURT




CINCINNATI
, OH 4
5249



ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)(3)(
8) AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)




ISSUE:


OHIO HOUSE DISTRICT 28



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/26/2010
THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE
WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.




OHIO ELECTIONS
COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
025




COMPLAINANT:

GEORGE MOMIROV


COUNSEL
: PHIL HARMON




2642 CLIFTON RD.




6649 N. HIGH ST. STE. 105




COLUMBUS, OH 43221



WORTHINGTON, OH 43085



RESPONDENT:

OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY

COUNSEL:

MARIA

ARMSTRONG




211 S. FIFTH ST.





COLUMBUS, OH 43215





OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY




KEVIN DEWINE, CHAIRMAN




211 S. FIFTH ST.




COLUMBUS, OH 43215






ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)(3)(8) AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)




ISSUE:


REPUBLICAN STATE CENRAL COMMITTEE



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/26/2010
THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE
WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
026




COMPLAINANT:

DAVID P. BRAND






95 RICHMOND AVE.




LONDON, OH 43140




(H) 740
-
852
-
6323




(C) 614
-
623
-
6543




RESPONDENT:

BRENDA ADAMS





59 ELM ST.




LONDON, OH 43140




(H) 7405062086





LYNN ADAMS




59 ELM ST.




LONDON, OH 43140







OUR
COMMUNITY

NEWSPAPER




59 ELM ST.




LONDON, OH 43140







ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)(3)(8) AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)




ISSUE:


MADISON COUNTY COMMISSIONER



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/26/2010
THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THA
T THERE
WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
027




COMPLAINANT:

APRIL G FRYMAN




508 W BARRE RD




ARCHBOLD, OH 43502







RESPONDENT:

OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY

COUNSEL:

MARIA ARMSTRONG




211 S. FIFTH ST.





COLUMBUS, OH 43215





OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY




KEVIN DEWINE, CHAIRMAN




211 S. FIFTH ST.




COLUMBUS, OH 43215






ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)(8) AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)




ISSUE:


REPUBLICAN STATE CENRAL COMMITTEE



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/26/2010
THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE
WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
028




COMPLAINANT:

JEFF FRYMAN




508 W BARRE RD




ARCHBOLD, OH 43502







RESPONDENT:

OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY

COUNSEL:

MARIA ARMSTRONG




211 S. FIFTH ST.





COLUMBUS, OH 43215





OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY




KEVIN DEWINE, CHAIRMAN




211 S. FIFTH ST.




COLUMBUS, OH 43215






ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)(8) AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)




ISSUE:


REPUBLICAN STATE CENRAL COMMITTEE



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/26/2010
THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE
WAS N
O PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
029




COMPLAINANT:

BEN HOWARD




1520 CREEKWOOD LN.




TOLEDO, OH 43614







RESPONDENT:

YARBROUGH CAMPAIGN CMTE

COUNSEL:

DONALD BREY




BRADD SMITH, TREASURER

5800 MONROE ST. #B11




SYLVANIA, OH 43560






ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.21(B)(1) (FALSE STATEMENTS)




ISSUE:


JUDGE



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/29/2010 PRIOR TO THE COMMISSION TAKING THE MATTER
UNDER
CONSIDERATION, THE COMPLAINANT SUBMITTED TO THE
COMMISSION A REQUEST TO WITHDRAW THE COMPLAINT.
PURSUANT TO R.C. §3517.157(B), A MATTER MAY BE WITHDRAWN
WITHOUT FURTHER ACTION OF THE COMMISSION AT ANY TIME PRIOR
TO THE COMMISSION TAKING THE MATTER U
NDER CONSIDERATION.
THEREFORE, THE COMMISSION ALLOWED THE MATTER TO BE
WITHDRAWN WITHOUT ANY FURTHER ACTION.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
030




COMPLAINANT:

CRISTA CRIDDLE



COUNSEL:

CURT C. HARTMAN




7368
COMMONWEALTH DR.


3749 FOX POINT CT.




CINCINNATI, OH 45224



AMELIA, OH 45102







RESPONDENT:

LESLIE GHIZ




4136 ROSE HILL AVE.





CINCINNATI, OH 45229





FRIENDS OF LESLIE GHIZ




DAN VOGELPOHL, TREASURER




30 GARFIELD PLACE STE. 600




CINCINNAT
I, OH 45202






ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(A)(10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)




ISSUE:


HAMILTON COUNTY COMMISSIONER



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/29/2010 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE
WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISM
ISSED THE
COMPLAINT.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010G
-
031




COMPLAINANT:

CITIZENS FOR TOM WEIDMAN






8180 KEMPER RIDGE CT.





CINCINNATI, OH 45249






(O) 513
-
489
-
1350




(C) 513
-
324
-
5555



RESPONDENT:

CITIZENS FOR
MIKE WILSON




2195 DEER MEADOW DR.




CINCINNATI, OH 45240




513
-
652
-
5364




ALLEGATIONS:

3517.10
(
D1
) (
LATE FILING OF THE DESIGNATION OF TREASURER
)




ISSU
E:


STATE REPRESENTATIVE



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

5/13/2010
THE MATTER
WAS

WITHDRAWN BY THE COMPLAINANT.




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
032




COMPLAINANT:

JOANNE S. KEMMERER






2441 KENILWORTH AVE.





CINCINNATI, OH 45212









RESPONDENT:

OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY


COUNSEL:

MARIA
ARMSTRONG




211 S. FIFTH ST.





100 S. THIRD ST.




COLUMBUS, OH 43215




COLUMBUS, OH 43215









OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY

COUNSEL:

MARIA ARMSTRONG




KEVIN DEWINE, CHAIRMAN




211 S. FIFTH ST.





AMBER BURKE SPRENGARD




3040 FAIRFIELD AVE.




CINCINN
ATI, OH 45206




ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.21(B)(3)(8) AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)




ISSUE:


REPUBLICAN STATE CENTRAL COMMITTEE 9
TH

DISTRICT



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/29/2010 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE
WAS NO
PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
033




COMPLAINANT:

MICHAEL CANTWELL

COUNSEL
: W. STUART DORNETTE




3349 HARRISON AVE



BETH A BRYAN




CINCINNATI, OH 45211


TAFT
, STETTINIUS& HOLLISTER










425 WALNUT ST #1800










CINTI., OH 45202
-
3957










513 381
-
2838









FAX

513 381
-
0205











RESPONDEN

T:

CITIZENS FOR MONZEL


COUNSEL
:

CURT HARTMAN




J C MONZEL, TREASURER


3749 FOX POINT CT.




720 HAND

AVE




AMELIA, OH 45102




CINCINNATI, OH 45232



513 752
-
8800









hartmanlawfirm@fuse.net





CHRISTOPHER MONZEL




720 HAND AVENUE




CINCINNATI, OH 45232






ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)(8)(9) & (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)




ISSUE:


HAMILTON COUNTY COMMIS
SIONER



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

4/29/2010 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DISMISSED THE COMPLAINT
AS THE COMPLAINANT FAILED TO COMPLY WITH THE COMMISSION’S
RULES THAT REQUIRE AN AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLAINT SIGNED BY THE
COMPLAINANT.



OHIO ELE
CTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
034




COMPLAINANT:

MIKE CRABTREE




281 PINE LANE




LUCASVILLE, OH 45648





















RESPONDEN

T:

RON HADSELL FOR STATE

COUNSEL
:

DONALD J. MCTIGUE




REPRESENTATIVE COMMITTEE



50 E.
WALNUT ST.





LISA HADSELL, TREASURER



COLUMBUS, OH 43215




3756 STAGECOACH LN.




PORTSMOUTH, OH 45662




ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21 (FALSE STATEMENTS)




ISSUE:


STATE REPRESENTATIVE



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

5/3/2010 THE PROBABLE
CAUSE PANEL DISMISSED THE COMPLAINT AS
THE COMPLAINANT FAILED TO COMPLY WITH THE COMMISSION’S
RULES THAT REQUIRE AN AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLAINT SIGNED BY THE
COMPLAINANT.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
035




COMPLAINANT:

ANDR
EW GLENN




1125 RAYMIL RD.




HOLLAND, OH 43528





(419) 779
-
7593
















RESPONDEN

T:

ELECT STEINGRABER CAMPAIGN COMMITTEE

BILL “GRAX” ANDERSON, TREASURER




230 MAIN




TOLEDO, OH 43605




(419) 345
-
4639



ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)(8) (FALSE
STATEMENTS)




ISSUE:


LUCAS COUNTY COMMISSIONER



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

5/3/2010 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE
WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SU
MMARY SHEET




CASE NO. 2010E
-
036



COMPLAINANT:

JOHN A. BOYD




CUYAHOGA CO CENTRAL CMTE




WARD 6 PRECINCT G




2173 E. 84
TH

ST.




CLEVELAND, OH 44103





(216) 376
-
7738












RESPONDEN

T:

MARY JO JONES




2025 E. 81
ST

ST. APT.
216




CLEVELAND,
OH 44106





PHILLIP WHITE, WARD 6 CLUB LEADER




12402 BRITTON DR. #2




CLEVELAND, OH 44106





MAMIE J. MITCHELL




CLEVELAND CITY HALL





601 LAKESIDE AVE.




CLEVELAND, OH 44114



ALLEGATIONS:

3517.
21(B)(8) AND (10)

(FALSE STATEMENTS)





3517.22(B)
(1) AND (2) (FALSE STATEMENTS)



ISSUE:


CUYAHOGA CO DEMOCRATIC PARTY’S IMPORTANT CTRL CMTE


ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

9/30/2010

THE COMMISSION DISMISSED THE MATTER FOR THE



COMPLAINANT'S FAILURE TO PROSECUTE THE CASE.




OHIO
ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET



CASE NO. 2010E
-
037


(PAGE 1 OF 2)



COMPLAINANT:

WILIAM D. STETLER, SUPERINTENDENT

COUNSEL
: RICHARD ROSS




NORTHWEST LOCAL SCHOOL DIST.



MEANS, BICHIMER,




8614 ERIE AVE. N





BURKHOLDER & BAKER




CANAL
FULTON, OH 44614



1650 LAKE SHORE DR




330
-
854
-
2291






COLS., OH 43204
















RESPONDEN

T:

HUGH UTTERBACK




P.O. BOX 382




CANAL FULTON, OH 44614




330
-
418
-
7192


ALLEGATIONS:

3517.10(D)(1) (FAILURE TO REGISTER AS A PAC)




3517.20(A) (NO
DISCLAIMER)

3517.22(B) (FALSE STATEMENTS)




ISSUE:


ISSUE 7



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010

PRIORS:



DISPOSITION:

5/3/2010

THE COMMISSION FOUND NO PROBABLE CAUSE AS TO




STATEMENT NOS. 2, 3, 4, 5, 7 AND 10 AND DISMISSED THOSE





STATEMENTS FROM THE COMPLAIN
T. THE COMMISSION FOUND




PROBABLE CAUSE AS TO STATEMENT NOS. 1, 3, 6, 8, 9, 11, 12 AND 13




AND DETERMINED THESE STATEMENTS FOR A HEARING BEFORE




THE FULL COMMISSION.





01/06/2011

THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION OF




R.C. §3517.10(D)(1) AN
D §3517.20(A).





THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.22(B)




AS TO THE STATEMENTS:





1. “TAXPAY
ER MONEY IS USED
TO

PROVIDE SCHOOL EMPLOYEES




WITH $327,644 IN DENTAL AND LIFE INSURANCE PREMIUMS.”





3. “YET THEY WILL NOT REDUCE THE OV
ERLY GENEROUS PAY OR




FRINGE BENEFITS THAT IS BEING GIVEN TO TEACHERS,






ADMINISTRATORS AND OTHER SCHOOL PERSONNEL.”















OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET



CASE NO. 2010E
-
037


(CON’T PAGE 2 OF 2)



DISPOSITION:

6. “THE BASE INCREASES USUALLY AMOUNT TO AT LEAST THE COST



OF LIVING AND QUITE OFTEN MORE. IT NOT UNCOMMON FOR THE REAL



INCREASES IN PAY TO ANNUALLY AMOUNT TO 6% TO 13% EVERY




YEAR.”







8. “TEACHERS ARE ALMOST GUARANTEED EMPLOYMENT FOR LIF
E.”






9. “AT THIS RATE THE COST OF RUNNING OUR SCHOOLS
WILL DOUBLE




IN LESS THAN 10 YEARS.





11. “IF THE LEVY PASES YOU CAN BE SURE THAT INCREASES WILL BE



GIVEN TO ALL, AND YOU WILL PROBABLY SEE THE $65,000 JUMP TO




$66,300 OR MORE WITHIN MO
NTHS DUE TO A NEGOTIATED CONTRACT



ALREADY MADE WITH THE TEACHERS UNION.”





12. “TEACHERS I
N THE NORTHWEST LOCAL SCHOOLS G
ET AN





AUTOMATIC INCREASE FOR EACH OF THE FIRST 15YEARS OF TEACHING.



THIS INCREASE IS TYPICALLY BETWEEN 3 AND 5.5% BUT SO
ME YEARS



IT CAN LEAP BY 10% OR MORE.





13. “BUT 14% IS NOT ENOUGH FOR THE TEACHERS AS THEY ARE TRYING



TO GET STATE LEGISLATORS TO INCREASE THIS TO 16.5%.”



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
038




COMPLAINANT:

TOM
GROSSMANN




FRIENDS OF TOM GROSSMANN




4533 MORRIS COURT




MASON, OH 45040




513 257
-
6789







RESPONDEN

T:

TOM ARISS




COUNSEL
:

WILLIAM KAUFMAN




TOM
ARISS FOR COMMISSIONER COMMI

144 E MULBERRY ST




234 IROQUOIS DRIVE




P O BOX 280




LEBANON, O
H 45036




LEBANON, OH 45036




513 932
-
6743






513 932
-
1515











513 932
-
9172




ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)(10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)




OFFICE:


WARREN
COUNTY COMMISSIONER



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010D
-
039




COMPLAINANT:

RONALD MAAG




2075 SOUTH STATE ROUTE 123




LEBANON, OH 45036




513 932
-
4646




513 535
-
4331







RESPONDEN

T:

GINGER SADLER KUBALA


COUNSEL
:

DONALD J. MCTIGUE

FOR STATE REPRESENTATIVE



550 E.
WALNUT ST.




9993 SADLER CIRCLE




COLUMBUS, OH 43215




LOVELAND, OH 45140




513 677
-
9953


ALLEGATIONS:

3517.20(A)(2)(IMPROPER DISCLAIMER)




OFFICE:



OHIO HOUSE 35
TH

DISTRICT



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

5/13/2010 THE MATTER WAS
WITHDRAWN BY THE COMPLAINANT.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
040




COMPLAINANT:

FRANKLIN CO DEM PARTY

COUNSEL
:

DONALD J. MCTIGUE




ZACH MANIFOLD, EXEC
. DIR



550 E. WALNUT ST.




271 EAST STATE ST.




COLUMBUS, OH 43215




COLUMBUS, OH 43215
-
4342




614
-
224
-
1193



RESPONDEN

T:

OUR DEMOCRATIC ORGANIZATION




P.O. BOX 16914




COLUMBUS, OH 43216








JEFFREY BOND




4464 NORWELL DR. E




COLUMBUS, OH 43220


ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.21(B)(8) AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)



OFFICE:



OHIO SENATE 3
RD

DISTRICT



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

8/19/2010 THE COMMISSION ACCEPTED THE REQUEST TO WITHDRAW
THE COMPLAINT.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
041




COMPLAINANT:

RON HADSELL


COUNSEL:

DONALD MCTIGUE




3756 STAGECOACH LANE



550 E. WALNUT ST.





PORTSMOUTH, OH 45662



COLUMBUS, OH43215



RESPONDEN

T:

THE COMMITTEE TO ELECT MIKE CRABTREE




281 PINE LANE




LUCASVILLE, OH 45648







ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.21 (FALSE STATEMENTS)



OFFICE:



STATE REPRESENTATIVE


ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

5/3/2010 PRIOR TO THE COMMISSION TAKING THE MATTER UNDER
CONSIDERATION, COUNSEL FOR THE COMPLAINANT REQUESTED
THAT THE COMMISSION ALLOW THE COMPLAINANT TO WITHDRAW
THE COMPLAI
NT. PURSUANT TO R.C. §3517.157(B), A MATTER MAY BE
WITHDRAWN WITHOUT FURTHER ACTION OF THE COMMISSION AT
ANY TIME PRIOR TO THE COMMISSION TAKING THE MATTER UNDER
CONSIDERATION. THE COMMISSION ACCEPTED THE COMPLAINANT’S
REQUEST TO WITHDRAW THE COMPLAINT.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
042




COMPLAINANT:

LARGER FOR OHIO




5578 BLUEGRASS WAY




HILLIARD, OH 43026




(419) 305
-
4239




Larger4ohio@gmail.com




RESPONDEN

T:

JASON
RAFELD




3877 RUSHMORE DR.




COLUMBUS, OH 43220




(614) 459
-
1865




Jason.rafeld@beggscaudill.com






TIM RANKIN




2020 COVENTRY RD.




COLUMBUS, OH 43212




ts
r@olrlaw.com




ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.21
(B)(10)

(FALSE STATEMENTS)






OFFICE:



OHIO HOUSE DISTRICT 24


ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

5/13/2010 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE
WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISS
ED THE
COMPLAINT.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
043




COMPLAINANT:

RONALD MAAG




2075 SOUTH STATE ROUTE 123




LEBANON, OH 45036




(H) 513 932
-
4646




(C) 513 535
-
4331







RESPONDEN

T:

GINGER SADLER KUBALA

COUNSEL:

DONALD J. MCTIGUE

FOR STATE REPRESENTATIVE



550 E WALNUT ST.




9993 SADLER CIRCLE




COLUMBUS, OH 43215




LOVELAND, OH 45140




513 677
-
9953


ALLEGATIONS:

3517.20(A)(2) (IMPROPER DISCLAIMER)




3517.21(B)(1) (FALSE STATEMENT)




OFFICE:



OHIO HOUSE 35
TH

DISTRICT



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

5/13/2010 PRIOR TO THE COMMISSION TAKING THE MATTER UNDER
CONSIDERATION, THE COMPLAINANT SUBMITTED TO THE
COMMISSION A REQUEST TO WITHDRAW THE COMPLAINT.
PURSUANT TO R.C. §3517.157(B), A MATTER

MAY BE WITHDRAWN
WITHOUT FURTHER ACTION OF THE COMMISSION AT ANY TIME PRIOR
TO THE COMMISSION TAKING THE MATTER UNDER CONSIDERATION.
THEREFORE, THE COMMISSION ALLOWED THE MATTER TO BE
WITHDRAWN WITHOUT ANY FURTHER ACTION.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE

SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010D
-
044




COMPLAINANT:

RONALD MAAG




2075 SOUTH STATE ROUTE 123




LEBANON, OH 45036




(H) 513 932
-
4646




(C) 513 535
-
4331






RESPONDEN

T:

GINGER SADLER KUBALA

COUNSEL
:

DONALD J. MCTIGUE

FOR STATE REPRESENTATIVE



550
E. WALNUT ST.




9993 SADLER CIRCLE




COLUMBUS, OH 43215




LOVELAND, OH 45140




513 677
-
9953



ALLEGATIONS:

3517.20(A)(2) (IMPROPER DISCLAIMER)








OFFICE:



OHIO HOUSE 35
TH

DISTRICT




ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

5/13/2010 THE M
ATTER WAS WITHDRAWN BY THE COMPLAINANT.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010D
-
045




COMPLAINANT:

LYNN ADAMS




59 ELM ST.




LONDON, OH 43140




(C) 740
-
974
-
5116






RESPONDEN

T:

MICHAEL BOERGER




4795 ROSEDALE RD.




MECHANICSBURG, OH 43044






ALLEGATIONS:

3517.20(A)(2) (IMPROPER DISCLAIMER)








OFFICE:


COUNTY COMMISSIONER



ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

6/17/2010 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.20(A)(2)
AND IMPOSED A FINE OF
$100
.



7/16/2010 RECEIVED CHECK # 10285 IN THE AMOUNT OF $100 FROM
MICHAEL K OR PAMELA J BOERGER FOR PAYMENT OF THE FINE
IMPOSED.



CASE CLOSED




OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
046




COMPLAINANT:

BILL HAYES





COUNSEL
:

STEPHANIE J. CEBULSKI




CITIZENS FOR BILL HAYES



191 W. NATIONWIDE BLVD




BILLIE FIORE, TREASURER



SUITE 300




58 CORBIN DR. NORTH




COLUMBUS, OH 43215




GRANVILLE, OH 43023




614
-
628
-
6880











(F) 614
-
628
-
6890



RESPONDEN

T:

DAN DODD




256 WILSHIRE DR.




HEBRON, OH 43025


CITIZENS TO ELECT DAN DODD




STEPHANIE DODD, TREASURER




256 N. MAIN ST.




NEW LEXINGTON, OH 43764






ALLEGATIONS:

3517.21(B)(9) AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)








OFFICE:


STATE REPRESENTATIVE



ELECTION:


MAY 4,

2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

5/13/2010 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE
WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET




CASE NO. 2010
G
-
047








PAGE 1 OF 2



COMPLAINANT:

LISA PERRY




4805 LANDER RD.




ORANGE VILLAGE, OH 44022




440
-
349
-
2699





DANIEL BROWN




28749 MILES RD.




ORANGE VILLAGE, OH 44022




440
-
248
-
6005




216
-
214
-
5591




RESPONDENT:

CITIZENS FOR A BETTER ORANGE




DAVID B. GALLUP, TREASURER




526
SUPERIOR AVE. E.




CLEVELAND, OH 44114




216
-
621
-
4636


DAVID B. GALLUP, ESQ




4389 ORANGEDALE RD.




ORANGE VILLAGE, OH 44022




216
-
831
-
3125




216
-
621
-
4636





JOSEPH A. DUBYAK, ESQ





4139 LANDER RD.




ORANGE VILLAGE, OH 44022




216
-
464
-
5429




21
6
-
241
-
0300





KRISTEN DUBYAK




4139 LANDER RD.




ORANGE VILLAGE, OH 44022




216
-
464
-
5429






ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.13 (UNLAWFUL TRANSFER OF FUNDS BETWEEN ACCOUNTS)

§3517.13(A
-
E) (INCOMPLETE OR INACCURATE CAMPAIGN FINANCE REPORTS)

§3517.13(F) (EXCESSIVE C
ASH CONTRIBUTIONS PER ELECION)

§3517.13(G) (CONCEALMENT OR MISREPRESENTATION OF CONTRIBUTIONS
OR EXPENDITURES
)




§3517.102(B) AND (C) (EXCESSIVE CONTRIBUTIONS)




§3517.105 (INDEPENDENT CAMPAIGN EXPENDITURES)










CASE NO. 2010G
-
047








PAGE 2 OF 2


OFFICE:




ELECTION:


MAY 4, 2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

7/1/2010 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(G)(1) AND
IMPOSED A FINE OF $500. THE COMMISSION THEN FOUND A VIOLATION OF
R.C. §3517.13(D) AND IMPOSED A FINE OF $100.

CONSOLIDATED
WITH 2010R
-
280
SAME ALLEGATIONS.



9/30/2010 THE COMMISSION RECEIVED CHECK #2215 IN THE AMOUNT OF $600
FROM DAVID B GALLUP FOR PAYMENT OF THE FINE IMPOSED.



CASE CLOSED



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010D
-
048




COMPLAINANT:

JOE PRICE







8390 CHERRY HILL LANE




BROADVIEW HTS., OH 44147









RESPONDEN

T:

SAMUEL J. ALAI


COUNSEL:

DOMINIC J. COLETTA




4331 E. WALLINGS RD.



55 PUBLIC SQUARE STE. 1200




BROADVIEW HTS., OH 44147


CLEVELAND, OH 44113






ALLEGATIONS:

§3
517.10(G) (INDEPENDENT EXPENDITURE)

§3517.20(A)(2) AND (8) (IMPROPER DISCLAIMER)




§3517.105(B)(2)(b) (INDEPENDENT EXPENDITURES)








OFFICE:


BROADVIEW HTS. MAYOR


ELECTION:


NOVEMBER 4, 2009


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

7/1/2010 THE COMMISSION DISMISSED
THE COMPLAINT OF THE BASIS
OF RES JUDICATA.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET



CASE NO. 2010E
-
049



COMPLAINANT:

BOB GIBBS FOR CONGRESS

COUNSEL
: MARIA ARMSTRONG




6992 TOWNSHIP RD. 466




BRICKER & ECKLER





LAKEVILLE, OH 44638




100 S. T
HIRD ST




330
-
763
-
1224






COLUMBUS, OH 43215










(BUS
)


614
-
227
-
8821


RESPONDEN

T:

ZACH SPACE FOR CONGRESS CMT
E
COUNSEL
:RITCHEY HOLLENBAUGH




726 SIXTEENTH ST. NE





366 E. BROAD ST.




MASSILLON, OH 44646





COLUMBUS, OH 43215


ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.21(B)(9) AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)


OFFICE:


CONGRESS


ELECTION:




PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

8/19/2010 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF
R.C. §3517.21(B)(9) BY CLEAR
AND CONVINCING EVIDENCE AS TO THE STATEMENT:






1.) “GIBBS VOTED
HIMSELF A PAY RAISE.”


THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLTION OF R.C. §3517.21(B)(9) BY CLEAR AND
CONVINCING EVIDENCE AS TO THE STATEMENT:


2.) “DID GIBBS GIVE TAX BREAKS TO FAMILIES? NO. HE GAVE THEM TO GOLF
COURSES. SO WHEN GIBBS TALKS TAXES, CHECK YOUR WALLE
T. GIBBS:
HIGHER TAXES FOR YOU…”


THE COMMISSION THEN FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.21(B)(10) BY CLEAR AND
CONVINCING EVIDENCE AS TO THE STATEMENT:


1.) “GIBBS VOTED HIMSELF A PAY RAISE.”


THE COMMISSION DECLARED AN ADMINISTRATIVE DISMISSAL FOR LACK OF
A
MAJORITY VOTE AS TO THE STATEMENT:


2.) “DID GIBBS GIVE TAX BREAKS TO FAMILIES? NO. HE GAVE THEM TO GOLF
COURSES. SO WHEN GIBBS TALKS TAXES, CHECK YOUR WALLET. GIBBS:
HIGHER TAXES FOR YOU…”


THE COMMISSION THEN CONSOLIDATED CASE NOS 2010E
-
049 AND
2010E
-
050 AND
ALLOWED THE FINDING OF A VIOLATION TO STAND AS THE PENALTY FOR THE
VIOLATION.

OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET



CASE NO. 2010E
-
050


COMPLAINANT:

BOB GIBBS FOR CONGRESS


COUNSEL
: MARIA ARMSTRONG




6992 TOWNSHIP RD. 466




LAKEVILLE, OH 44638




330
-
763
-
1224









RESPONDEN

T:

ZACH SPACE FOR CONGRESS CMTE
COUNSEL
:RITCHEY HOLLENBAUGH




726 SIXTEENTH ST. NE





366 E. BROAD ST.




MASSILLON, OH 44646





COLUMBUS, OH 43215





ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.21(B)(9) AND (10) (
FALSE STATEMENTS)


OFFICE:


CONGRESS


ELECTION:




PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

8/19/2010 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.21(B)(9) BY CLEAR
AND CONVINCING EVIDENCE AS TO THE STATEMENT:






1.) “GIBBS VOTED HIMSELF A PAY RAISE.”


THE COMMISSION
FOUND A VIOLTION OF R.C. §3517.21(B)(9) BY CLEAR AND
CONVINCING EVIDENCE AS TO THE STATEMENT:


2.) “DID GIBBS GIVE TAX BREAKS TO FAMILIES? NO. HE GAVE THEM TO GOLF
COURSES. SO WHEN GIBBS TALKS TAXES, CHECK YOUR WALLET. GIBBS:
HIGHER TAXES FOR YOU…”


THE

COMMISSION THEN FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.21(B)(10) BY CLEAR AND
CONVINCING EVIDENCE AS TO THE STATEMENT:


1.) “GIBBS VOTED HIMSELF A PAY RAISE.”


THE COMMISSION DECLARED AN ADMINISTRATIVE DISMISSAL FOR LACK OF A
MAJORITY VOTE AS TO THE STATEMENT:


2.) “DID GIBBS GIVE TAX BREAKS TO FAMILIES? NO. HE GAVE THEM TO GOLF
COURSES. SO WHEN GIBBS TALKS TAXES, CHECK YOUR WALLET. GIBBS:
HIGHER TAXES FOR YOU…”


THE COMMISSION THEN CONSOLIDATED CASE NOS 2010E
-
049 AND 2010E
-
050 AND
ALLOWED THE FINDING OF A VIOL
ATION TO STAND AS THE PENALTY FOR THE
VIOLATION.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010E
-
051




COMPLAINANT:

MARGARET DEL FAVERO

COUNSEL
:

PAMALA PETAS




3779 COOPER RD.





CINCINNATI, OH 45241




513
-
386
-
8639





RESPONDEN

T:

JIM SUMNER





4595 COOPER RD




CINCINNATI, OH 45242








SAL WERTHEIM





3733 FALLENTREE LANE






CINCINNATI, OH 45241







ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.21(B)(
4
)
(8)(9)
AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)








OFFICE:


BLUE ASH PRECINCT 5B EXECUTIVE OFFICE


ELECTION:




PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

7/1/2010 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE
WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE
COMPLAINT.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010D
-
052




COMPLAINANT:

KEVIN CRONI
N, ESQ.




THE BROWN HOIST BLDG.




4403 SAINT CLAIR AVE.





CLEVELAND, OH 44103
-
1125




(P) 216
-
337
-
0615



RESPONDEN

T:

COMMITTEE TO ELECT DANITA LOVE




20609 SELFRIDGE PKWY.




HIGHLAND HILLS, OH 44122




(P) 216
-
295
-
1193





DOMINION EAST OHIO




1201

E. 55
TH

ST.




CLEVELAND, OH 44103
-
1028




(P) 216
-
736
-
6855








ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.20 (INCORRECT OR IMPROPER DISCLAIMER)




§3517.105 (
EXPENDITURES
)




OEC ADVISORY OPINION 96ELC
-
10



OFFICE:


CUYAHOGA CO. DISTRICT 5 COUNCIL


ELECTION:




PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

8/19/2010 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.20
AGAINST THE COMMITTEE TO ELECT DANITA LOVE BUT FOR GOOD
CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR
FURTHER PROSECUTION. THE COMMISSION THEN FOUND NO
VIOLATION AGAINST

DOMINION EAST OHIO.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010G
-
053




COMPLAINANT:

FRIENDS OF WILLIAM D. MASON
COUNSEL
:

DONALD MCTIGUE, ESQ




THOMAS REGAS, TREASURER



COREY COLOMBO, ESQ




5114 SASSAFRAS DR.




550 E. WALNUT ST.




PARMA, OH 44134





COLUMBUS, OH 43215



RESPONDEN

T:

SELF REFERRAL






ALLEGATIONS:

OEC ADVISORY OPINION 99ELC
-
03



OFFICE:


CUYAHOGA CO. PROSECUTNG ATTORNEY


ELECTION:


11/3/09


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

7/1/2010 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF
R.C. §3517.13(O)
BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE
MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010G
-
054




COMPLAINANT:

STEPHANIE L. ZULLO




541 W. HIGHLAND DR.




ZANESVILLE, OH 4
3701




(740) 452
-
0830





JONATHAN CRONIN




1016 SUNSET AVE.




ZANESVILLE, OH 43701




(740) 319
-
1933



RESPONDEN

T:

AMERICAN PRIDE POWER EQUIP
.

INC.

COUNSEL
:

DONALD MCTIGUE




RYAN DODSON, OWNER





550 E WALNUT ST.




1006 MAPLE AVE.






COLS, OH
43215




ZANESVILLE, OH 43701




(740) 454
-
7236






ALLEGATIONS:

§3599.03 (FAILURE TO FILE A 30
-
B
-
1 FORM)



OFFICE:


CITY COUNCIL


ELECTION:


11/3/09


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

8/19/2010 THE COMMISSION DISMISSED THE COMPLAINT FOR AN
IMPROPER NOTARIZATION.



OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010G
-
055




COMPLAINANT:

MCINTOSH FOR JUDGE COMMITTEE




CAROLYN FRANCIS, TREASURER




2168 CITYGATE DR.




COLUMBUS, OH 43219



RESPONDEN

T:

SELF REFERRAL






ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.13(D)
(INACCURATE 2009 ANNUAL REPORT)



OFFICE:




ELECTION:




PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

8/19/2010 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(D)
BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE
MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.



OHIO ELECTIONS
COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010G
-
056


COMPLAINANT:

STEPHANIE L. ZULLO




541 W. HIGHLAND DR.




ZANESVILLE, OH 43701




(740) 452
-
0830





JONATHAN CRONIN




1016 SUNSET AVE.




ZANESVILLE, OH 43701




(740) 319
-
1933



RESPONDEN

T:

HEATHER
SANDS




587 BRIGHTON BLVD.




ZANESVILLE, OH 43701








ANDREW ROBERTS




710 LOCUST AVE.




ZANESVILLE, OH 43701





JEFF TILTON




848 BROWN ST.




ZANESVILLE, OH 43701





CAM TWAROG




425 KARL DR.




ZANESVILLE, OH 43701





DAVID J. DITTMAR




61
S. 4
TH

ST.




ZANESVILLE, OH 43701



ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.10 (
CONTRIBUTIONS/EXPENDITURES
)



OFFICE:


CITY COUNCIL


ELECTION:


11/3/09


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

8/19/2010

THE COMMISSION DISMISSED THE COMPLAINT FOR AN IMPROPER
NOTARIZATION.


OHIO ELECTIONS
COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010G
-
057




COMPLAINANT:

STEVEN A. FUSNER




6187 WELSH RD.




NASHPORT, OH 43830




(740)
454
-
3568



RESPONDEN

T:

CHIEF JOHN BENSON


COUNSEL
:

DONALD BREY




5205 BELLVIEW DR.

ZANESVILLE, OH 43701


TROY LOWE,

ASSISTANT CHIEF




2780 TARKMAN DR.




NASHPORT, OH 43830





MUSKINGUM TOWNSHIP FIRE DEPARTMENT




SHERRY BUTLER, TREASURER




6465 FRAZEYSBURG RD. APT. D




NASHPORT, OH 43830



ALLEGATIONS:

§3599.03

(
FAILURE TO FILE A 30
-
B
-
1 FORM
)



OFFICE:


MUSKINGUM

TWNSHP TRUSTEE


ELECTION:


11/3/09


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

9/2/2010 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION OF R.C. §3599.03 AS
ALLEGED IN THE COMPLAINT.





OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET





CASE NO. 2010G
-
058




COMPLAINANTS:

DEBORAH WALSH



COUNSEL
: BRIAN K MURPHY




EXEC. DIR.




MURRAY, MURPHY MOUS & BASIL LLP




SUMMIT CO REPUBLICAN PARTY

1533 LAKE SHORE DR, SUITE 150




520 MAIN ST., SUITE 2437


COLUMBUS, OH 43204




AKRON, OH 44311



614 488
-
0400 X2




330 434
-
9151



FAX:

614 488
-
0401





DOUG PRIESSE




CHAIRMAN




EXECUTIVE COMM OF THE FRANKLIN CO REP PARTY




14 E GAY ST




COLUMBUS, OH 43215




614 224
-
3939







RESPONDENT:

RICHARD CORDRAY


COUNSEL
:

DONALD J MCTIG
U
E




THE CORDRAY COMMITTEE


550 E WALNUT ST.




340 E FULTON ST




COLUMBUS, OH 43215




COLUMBUS, OH 43215



263
-
7000




220
-
4500




FAX:

263
-
7078



ALLEGATIONS:

§
3517.109
(B),
(
C
)
, (D) AND (E)
(FAILURE TO DISPOSE OF EXCESS FUNDS AS




STATUTORILY
APPROVED)



OFFICE:


ATTORNEY GENERAL



ELECTION:


5/4/2010


PRIORS:




DISPOSITION:

9/2/2010

THE COMPLAINT WAS WITHDRAWN BY THE COMPLAINANT.





OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION

CASE SUMMARY SHEET




CASE NO. 2010
E
-
05
9


COMPLAINANTS:

JIM A. BERNS





1220 WEST NORTH BENT RD.






CINCINNATI, OH 45224





513
-
708
-
0815




jaberns@hotmail.com





RESPONDENT:

JENNIFER BRUNNER





OHIO SECRETARY OF STATE






180 E. BROAD ST. 16
TH

FLOOR






COLUMBUS, OH 43215










KEITH FABER




OHIO SENATE




SENATE BUILDING, ROOM 138




COLUMBUS, OH 43215






FRED STRAHORN




OHIO SENATE




SENATE BUILDING, ROOM 128




COLUMBUS, OH 43215





WILLIAM N. MORGAN




8740 STOUTSVILLE PIKE




STOUTSVILLE, OH 43154





REBECCA L.. EGELHOFF, ESQ.




THE LAW OFFICES OF SEAN A. MENTEL, LLC




88
E. BROAD ST. SUITE 2000




COLUMBUS, OH 43215







ALLEGATIONS:

§3517.22 (FALSE STATEMENTS)

OTHER ALLEGATIONS THAT DO NOT FALL WITHIN THE

JURISDICTION OF THE OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION


OFFICE:


OHIO BALLOT BOARD MEMBERS



ELECTION:




PRIORS:




DISPOSI
TION:

THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DISMISSED ALL ALLEGATIONS CONTAINED IN